批评者将拟推出的折扣食品会员卡与这位市长反对的选民身份证法相提并论
2026年8月3日 美国东部时间下午5:13 / 福克斯新闻
作者:查尔斯·克赖茨
曼达尼的食品提案包含身份验证计划遭民主党人反对《拯救美国法案
纽约市长佐赫兰·K·曼达尼与纽约市经济发展公司(NYCEDC)负责人珍妮·帕克商讨如何确保只有纽约市民才能使用市属超市。
NEW 您现在可以收听福克斯新闻文章!
blob:https://www.foxnews.com/253e46fd-ef2c-4b93-86e6-569ce1486a9a
收听本文
5分钟
纽约市市长佐赫兰·曼达尼的市属超市计划周一遭到批评,此前一名市政府官员告诉记者,该市可能会采用“类似图书馆卡的系统”,以防止有人滥用该30%折扣市场。
曼达尼回答了一名记者的提问,该记者询问如何防止有人将人为压低价格批量购买的食品以建议零售价或更高价格转售。
市长回应称,政府超市的征求建议书明确表示“这是一项让纽约市民能够负担得起食物的计划,而非让人们通过转售快速牟利的计划。我将交由我们的经济发展公司负责人珍妮·帕克补充更多细节。”
曼达尼的市属超市计划可能让纳税人承担每一根香蕉买单
纽约市市长佐赫兰·曼达尼于2026年7月27日在纽约市布鲁克林区的一个食品分发中心发表讲话时手持香蕉。(斯宾塞·普拉特/盖蒂图片社
帕克的后续发言引发了争议,考虑到曼达尼和许多民主党人坚决反对选民身份证法,以及共和党人推动的《拯救美国法案》正在国会推进。
“[我们]正努力确保我们的目标是纽约市民,可能会采用类似图书馆卡的方式,同时我们会管控购买者,目标群体是普通纽约市民。”帕克说道。
“因此,我们对此保持警惕,并将确保落实所有相关措施,确保此类情况不会发生。”
参议员马克·华纳在ABC采访中因不实选民身份证言论遭谴责
当被问及帕克提及可能采用身份证类系统的表态与反对选民身份证法之间明显的矛盾时,曼达尼的一名发言人表示这是风马牛不相及。
“将其与选民身份证法或《拯救美国法案》相比较根本不恰当。这既不是身份识别系统,也不是核实某人身份、居住地或收入的机制。”曼达尼的发言人说道。
“这是一个实用的库存管理工具,以确保平价食品留给真正需要的人能够买到,而不是被抢购一空用于转售。”
**专家抨击曼达尼的食品计划是“幻象”,最终将由纳税人买单
发言人特别指出,这是针对记者提出的批量采购问题作出的回应,而非宾夕法尼亚州、新泽西州或纽约州北部的居民是否能够在这家补贴超市购物的问题。
“明确说明:纽约市的超市将对所有人开放。”发言人说道。
“不会有任何核实身份、居住权或收入的系统,也不会要求任何人出示身份证才能购物。”
发言人表示,替代“身份证”的方案是,超市可能会采用类似其他超市如ShopRite、Food Lion或Weis的忠诚度计划的“顾客卡”。
这张“顾客卡”将由市属超市的“私营运营商”设计,以“帮助管理库存,防止人们大量购买折扣主食用于转售”,其唯一目的是“确保优惠惠及真正需要购买食物的家庭能享受到这些优惠。”
订阅获取政治新闻通讯
东哈莱姆的拉美集市拉马尔克塔被选为纽约市长佐赫兰·曼达尼于2026年4月14日宣布的首家市属超市选址。(肯德尔·罗德里格斯/《新闻日报》RM/盖蒂图片社
发言人补充道,顾客无需通过市政厅或任何机构申请。
批评者并不买账。
“这就是政府补贴食品的身份证。”费城电台主持人里奇·泽奥利说道。
“毕竟,我们必须确保没有人越境,要是真有人越境,就会报警。很高兴看到曼达尼现在支持身份证(只是投票不需要身份证)、边境管控和执法。”泽奥利在推特上写道。
前得克萨斯州国会候选人尼克·普朗布在X平台上评论道:“曼达尼想要保护纳税人资助的超市,不让非纽约市民进入,他们需要出示身份证才能进入。这种离谱到编都编不出来。”
前弗吉尼亚州总检察长杰森·米亚雷斯——支持选民身份证法,同时反对弗吉尼亚州近期为民主党利益重划国会选区的失败尝试——也批评了这位市长。
“那我就明白了:纳税人资助的超市?不拿出有效身份证,否则你连牛奶都买不到。”米亚雷斯说道。
“投票选举决定税收如何使用的人?出示有效身份证却被认为是‘种族主义’和‘压迫’。难以置信。”他说道。
当被问及市长办公室是否认为忠诚度卡系统属于身份证明形式时,曼达尼的一名发言人让福克斯新闻数字频道查阅了征求建议书(RFP)中要求潜在超市运营商必须遵守的条款:
“运营商将创建一个免费自愿的会员卡计划,以监控销售活动,并实施折扣计划及相关的需求管理措施。该优惠卡不得作为进入纽约市超市实体场所的必要条件,并且应向任何申请的人免费提供。”条款中写道。
“说不通啊。”福克斯新闻主持人肖恩·汉尼提补充道。
点击此处下载福克斯新闻APP
纽约州共和党联邦众议员克劳迪娅·特尼补充道:“所以为了防止有人滥用系统,政府超市需要身份证,但投票需要身份证就不行?懂了。”
《拯救美国法案》支持者、印第安纳州共和党参议员吉姆·班克斯也在X平台上补充道,这种虚伪行为必须“停止”。
“民主党人:一边战斗,确保你在选举投票前无需出示身份证。另一边,又希望你在进入超市前出示身份证。”
“讽刺意味太浓了。”X平台首席执行官埃隆·马斯克说道。
Mamdani’s grocery giveaway hits ID snag as critics cry foul: ‘Make it make sense’
Critics compare the proposed customer card for discounted groceries to voter ID laws the mayor opposes
August 3, 2026 5:13pm EDT / Fox News
By Charles Creitz
Mamdani grocery proposal includes ID verification as Dems oppose SAVE America Act
New York Mayor Zohran K. Mamdani and New York City Economic Development Corporation (NYCEDC) Jeanny Pak discuss ways to ensure only New Yorkers use the city-run grocery stores.
NEW You can now listen to Fox News articles!
blob:https://www.foxnews.com/253e46fd-ef2c-4b93-86e6-569ce1486a9a
Listen to this article
5 min
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s game plan for government-run grocery stores faced criticism Monday after a city official told reporters a “library-card-esque system” may be employed to prevent abuse of the 30% discounted markets.
Mamdani took a question from a reporter who asked about preventing bulk purchases of groceries at the artificial discount from being re-sold at MSRP or higher.
The mayor responded that the government grocery Request-for-Proposal makes clear “this is a program for New Yorkers to be able to put food on the table, not a program for people to be able to make a quick buck through reselling. I’m going to pass it over to our EDC head, Jeanny Pak, to add some additional details.”
MAMDANI’S CITY GROCERY PLAN COULD LEAVE TAXPAYERS PAYING FOR EVERY BANANA
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani holds up bananas as he speaks at a food distribution center on July 27, 2026, in the Brooklyn borough of New York City.(Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
It was Pak’s follow-up that raised eyebrows, given Mamdani and many Democrats’ staunch opposition to voter ID and Republicans’ SAVE America Act moving through Congress.
“[W]e are looking to make sure that we target New Yorkers, whether it be a sort of a library card-esque thing, and also we manage who’s buying and that is focused on everyday New Yorkers,” Pak said.
“So, we are mindful of that, and so we’re going to make sure that we have all the things in place to ensure that that does not happen.”
SEN MARK WARNER CALLED OUT IN ABC INTERVIEW FOR INACCURATE VOTER ID CLAIMS
When asked about the apparent divergence between Pak’s response referencing a possible ID card-type system and opposition to voter ID, a Mamdani spokesperson said it was an apples-to-oranges contrast.
“Comparisons to voter ID laws or the SAVE Act simply do not apply. This is not an identification system, nor is it a mechanism to verify who someone is, where they live, or how much they earn,” Mamdani’s spokesperson said.
“It is a practical inventory management tool to ensure affordable groceries remain available for the people who need them instead of being cleared off shelves for resale.”
EXPERTS SCORCH MAMDANI’S GROCERY PLAN AS AN ‘ILLUSION’ THAT WILL HAVE TAXPAYERS FOOTING THE BILL
The spokesperson pointed to the mayor’s comments specifically regarding bulk-buying concerns, saying that was the premise of the reporter’s question — not whether people from Pennsylvania, New Jersey or upstate New York would be able to shop at the subsidized outlets.
“To be absolutely clear: NYC Grocery stores will be open to everyone,” the spokesperson said.
“There will be no system to verify identity, residency, or income, and no one will be asked to show ID to shop.”
Instead of an “ID,” the spokesperson said the stores may employ a “customer card” similar to loyalty programs at other grocers like ShopRite, Food Lion or Weis.
The “customer card” would be designed by the “private operator” of the city-run store to “help manage supply and prevent people from buying large quantities of discounted staples for resale” and is strictly intended to “make sure the savings reach families putting food on the table.”
SIGN UP TO GET THE POLITICS NEWSLETTER
La Marqueta, a Latino marketplace in East Harlem, is chosen as the site of the first city-owned grocery store announced by NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani, on April 14, 2026.(Kendall Rodriguez/Newsday RM/Getty Images)
Customers will not need to apply through City Hall or any agency, the spokesperson added.
Critics were unconvinced.
“ID for government cheese,” said Philadelphia radio host Rich Zeoli.
“After all, we have to make sure no one crosses the border and if they do, the police will be called. So it’s good to see Mamdani now supports ID (just not for voting), border control, and law enforcement,” Zeoli tweeted.
Former Texas congressional candidate Nick Plumb commented on X that “Mamdani wants to protect taxpayer funded grocery store[s] from non-NYC residents they’ll need an ID card to enter. You can[t] make this up.”
Former Virginia Attorney General Jason Miyares, a supporter of voter ID who also opposed the Old Dominion’s recent failed attempt to redraw congressional lines to Democrats’ advantage, also criticized the mayor.
“So let me get this straight: Taxpayer-funded grocery store? Better show a valid ID or you can’t buy milk,” Miyares said.
“Voting for the people who decide how those taxes get spent? A valid ID is somehow ‘racist’ and ‘oppressive’. Unbelievable,” he said.
When asked whether the mayor’s office believed the loyalty card system constituted a form of identification, a Mamdani spokesperson directed Fox News Digital to a paragraph in the Request for Proposal (RFP) that prospective store operators must follow:
“The Operator(s) will create a voluntary free-to-access membership card program to monitor sales activity, and implement the discount program and any associated demand management measures. The savings card shall not be required for physical access to N.Y.C. Groceries site(s) and shall be made easily available to any individual requesting one,” the section read.
“Make it make sense,” added FOX News host Sean Hannity.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
New York Republican Congresswoman Claudia Tenney added: “So ID for government grocery stores to stop people abusing the system is fine, but requiring ID to vote not? Got it.”
SAVE Act supporter Sen. Jim Banks, R-Ind., added on X that the hypocrisy must “stop.”
“Democrats: Are fighting to ensure you don’t have to show an ID before voting in our elections. Also Democrats: Want you to show an ID before entering a supermarket.”
“Oh, the irony is too much,” said X CEO Elon Musk.