马姆达尼解散纽约警察局防暴部队的计划被前警方领导人斥为“烟雾弹”


前纽约警察局官员称,尽管市长作出承诺,战略反应大队将只是更名而非解散

作者:汉娜·布伦南、彼得·达布罗斯卡,福克斯新闻

发布时间:美国东部时间2026年11月21日 6:00

观看:前纽约警察局官员抨击马姆达尼解散战术部队的决定是“骗局”

前纽约警察局局长约翰·切尔和前纽约警察局督察保罗·莫罗指责纽约市市长佐兰·马姆达尼解散战略反应大队的新举措,是为了讨好其选民基础,而在抗议应对方面几乎没有做出任何实质性改变。

NEW You can now listen to Fox News articles!

blob:https://www.foxnews.com/e86e761b-68e8-4346-b73a-f32d64ad67af

收听本文

5分钟

两位前纽约警察局高级官员向福克斯新闻数字频道透露,纽约市市长佐兰·马姆达尼解散该市战术警察部队的计划并非表面看起来那样。

他们认为,这一举动是一场政治花招:尽管这位社会主义市长承诺彻底解散该部队,但负责处理暴力抗议的专业警员将被更名重组。

“问题在于……普通纽约民众并不理解所有这些操纵手段,”前纽约警察局局长约翰·切尔告诉福克斯新闻数字频道,“他们对此感到焦虑。”

“但说到底,这不过是烟雾弹而已,”他补充道。

独家报道:退休警佐在感恩节游行前就马姆达尼对纽约警察局的改组发出警告

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/zohran-mamdani-new-york-city.jpg

纽约市市长佐兰·马姆达尼于2026年1月6日在纽约市纽约警察局总部出席新闻发布会。(斯宾塞·普拉特/盖蒂图片社)

解散战略反应大队(SRG)并以“首创的”平民对话团队取而代之的举措,实现了马姆达尼在关于此举的新闻稿开篇承诺的竞选纲领之一。

但切尔和退休纽约警察局督察保罗·莫罗质疑,这是否只是讨好市长左翼选民基础的幌子,实则是重组而非解散。他们表示,该部队很可能会以新名称重建,以继续应对大规模抗议、重大犯罪和反恐行动。

“这里的骗局在于,战略反应大队目前只是被更名为一个未知的名称,”切尔表示。

“首先,马姆达尼确实补充说,如有必要,将部署穿制服的警员采取更有力的执法行动,”莫罗称,“那么真正改变了什么呢?他只是更改了该部队的名称,并在这些穿制服的警员与抗议者之间插入了这支平民部队。”

新提议的平民主导型社区对话与降级部门(CDDD)旨在作为缓冲,在大型示威活动中,在执勤警员与抗议者之间发挥作用。

“社会主义与公共安全无法并存,”切尔坚称。

马姆达尼办公室未回应福克斯新闻数字频道就其计划遭到批评一事提出的置评请求。

纽约警察呼吁警方保护:他逮捕的抗议者现身其住所,骚扰其家人

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/new-york-city-nypd-protest.jpg

2025年6月10日,美国纽约州纽约市26号联邦广场大楼外,纽约警察局警员在一场反ICE抗议活动中逮捕一名示威者。(穆斯塔法·巴西姆/阿纳多卢通讯社 via 盖蒂图片社)

两位前纽约警察局官员都警告称,如果和平抗议演变为暴力骚乱,依靠平民调解闹事人群可能会延误警方干预。他们表示,这会导致警员应对不断升级的局势,而非事先预防。

“一旦警员,无论被分配到何处,变得被动而非主动,公共安全就会受到损害,”切尔说,“而且[当警员]变得被动时,往往会有所克制,这可能导致警员受伤,也可能伤及平民。”

“这是此事固有的风险之一,”莫罗补充道,“你部署平民,他们试图进行交涉……等到平民转身说‘警察,我们需要帮助’时,可能已经太晚了。”

战略反应大队从纽约警察局情报与反恐局获取信息,以了解已知或可能发生的需要专业训练来平息的危险示威活动。

战略反应大队接受过处理暴力人群的训练,从口头劝诫开始。体能训练教会警员如何控制不配合的个体并将其带上警车。该部队常用的战术是自行车人群管控,警员可以排列自行车在人群中搭建路障,利用这些阵型进行人群控制。

“战略反应大队的作用是确保你拥有训练有素的警员,能够平息局势、控制局面,必要时还能管控失控的抗议活动,”莫罗说,“这也是他们仅在约6%的事件中部署的原因。”

马姆达尼与民主社会主义者废除警察和监狱的主张发生冲突

今年早些时候的一场预算听证会上指出,战略反应大队并不常处理和平抗议,大部分仅在抗议演变为暴力时部署。据报道,2025年纽约警察局共促成4255场抗议活动,战略反应大队的参与率约为6%。

战略反应大队的批评者,包括美国公民自由联盟纽约分会,称该部队因反恐专业化而本质上具有暴力性,声称其“压制抗议者”,无视“对第一修正案保护的关注”。

福克斯新闻数字频道审查的训练手册将“和平/配合”的人群与被认定为“暴力/不配合”的人群区分开来。它还将抗议者分为三类:“普通公民”“专业人士”和“无政府主义者”。

在“普通公民”抗议者的首个标识中,明确承认他们是在行使组织集会的第一修正案权利。

马姆达尼解散精锐部队后,佛罗里达州考虑挖走纽约警察局警员

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/BIKE-MANUAL.jpg

纽约警察局战略反应大队的自行车训练手册将抗议者分为三类:“普通公民”“专业人士”和“无政府主义者”。(纽约警察局)

尽管战略反应大队将被解散,但马姆达尼的计划仍可能要求警方在大型示威活动中到场。不过新的平民主导型团队将到场,试图在抗议显示出转变为暴力的迹象时进行平息。

马姆达尼尚未说明平民团队将在何时组建或上街。他还宣布成立第一修正案支持团队(FAST),这是一支30人的纽约警察局部队,将在社区对话与降级部门组建期间协助平息人群。

点击此处下载福克斯新闻应用

切尔已宣布将在2029年竞选纽约市市长,届时马姆达尼很可能正在寻求连任。他表示,他怀疑新团队至少要到2028年才会成形——即便最终能建成的话。

“所有这一切令人担忧的是市长及其幕僚和社会主义朋友管理这座城市的心态,”切尔说。

“如果他们如愿以偿,我们将沦为第三世界城市,而我不确定我们还能否恢复原状。”

汉娜是福克斯新闻数字频道政治团队的制作助理。

Mamdani’s plan to dismantle NYPD’s riot unit ripped as ‘smoke and mirrors’ by former force leaders

Ex-NYPD officials claim the Strategic Response Group will be rebranded rather than dissolved despite the mayor’s promise

By Hannah Brennan , Peter D’Abrosca Fox News

Published November 21, 2026 6:00am EST

WATCH: Ex-NYPD officials rip Mamdani’s decision to disband tactical unit as a ‘con’

Former NYPD Chief John Chell and former NYPD inspector Paul Mauro are accusing New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s new disbanding of the Strategic Response Group as a move to please his base, with little real change to protest response being made.

NEW You can now listen to Fox News articles!

blob:https://www.foxnews.com/e86e761b-68e8-4346-b73a-f32d64ad67af

Listen to this article

5 min

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s plan to gut the city’s tactical police unit is not what is seems, two former high-ranking NYPD officials tell Fox News Digital.

They argue the stunt is a political sleight of hand in which specialized officers responsible for handling violent protests will be rebranded under a different name despite the socialist mayor’s promise to disband it completely.

“The problem is…day-to-day New Yorkers don’t understand all this gas lighting,” former NYPD Chief John Chell told Fox News Digital. “And they feel the angst of it.”

“But at the end of all that, this is nothing more than smoke and mirrors,” he added.

EXCLUSIVE: RETIRED POLICE SERGEANT ISSUES WARNING OVER MAMDANI’S NYPD SHAKE-UP AHEAD OF THANKSGIVING PARADE

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/zohran-mamdani-new-york-city.jpg

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani attends a news conference at NYPD headquarters in New York City on Jan. 6, 2026.(Spencer Platt/Getty Images)

The move to dissolve the Strategic Response Group (SRG) and replace it with a “first-of-its-kind” civilian dialogue team fulfills one of Mamdani’s campaign promises — noted in the first sentence of his news release on the move.

But Chell and retired NYPD inspector Paul Mauro are questioning whether it’s all a facade to please the mayor’s left-wing base and is a restructuring rather than a disbandment. They say the unit will likely be rebuilt under a new name to continue dealing with mass protests, major crimes and counterterrorism.

“The con here is that the SRG is simply being rebranded into an unknown name right now,” Chell said.

“First of all, Mamdani did add…that there will be uniformed police standing by to take more forceful enforcement if necessary,” Mauro said. “So what really changed? Well, he changed the name of that unit and he inserted this civilian unit between those uniformed cops and the protesters.”

The newly proposed civilian-led Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD) is meant to work as a buffer between protesters and the on-duty police that will remain present at large demonstrations.

“Socialism and public safety do not go hand in hand,” Chell insisted.

Mamdani’s office did not respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment on the criticism of his plan.

NY COP CALLS FOR POLICE PROTECTIONS AFTER PROTESTER HE ARRESTED SHOWED UP TO HIS HOUSE, HARASSED HIS FAMILY

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/new-york-city-nypd-protest.jpg

NYPD officers arrest a demonstrator during an anti-ICE protest outside 26 Federal Plaza Building in New York City, New York, U.S., June 10, 2025.(Mostafa Bassim/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Both former NYPD officials warned that relying on civilians to mediate rowdy crowds could delay police intervention if a peaceful protest turns into a violent riot. This, he said, could leave officers responding to an escalating situation rather than preventing it in the first place.

“Once a cop, wherever they’re assigned, becomes reactive versus proactive — public safety suffers,” Chell said. “And [when cops] become reactive, they tend to hold back and that can get them hurt, and it can get civilians hurt.”

“That is one of the risks inherent in this thing,” Mauro added. “That you deploy the civilians, they’re trying to talk…and by the time the civilians turn around and say, ‘Police, we need help,’ it may be too late.”

SRG receives information from NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau to be kept aware of known or potentially dangerous demonstrations that will require specialized training to deescalate.

The SRG unit is trained to handle crowds that have turned violent, beginning with verbal de-escalation. The physical training teaches officers how to get a noncomplying individual and into police vans. A common tactic used by the SRG is bicycle crowd management where officers can line up their bikes to build a barricade in crowds, using those formations for crowd control.

“The purpose of the SRG was to make sure that you had highly trained officers who could diffuse, spin down, but then control if need be, protests that were getting out of hand,” Mauro said. “That’s why they were only deployed in about 6% of the instances.”

MAMDANI CLASHES WITH DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISTS’ PUSH TO ABOLISH POLICE AND PRISONS

In a budget hearing earlier this year it was noted the SRG did not often deal with peaceful protests, and were mostly only deployed for protests that turned violent. In 2025, NYPD reportedly facilitated 4,255 protests and the SRG was available for roughly 6% of them.

Critics of the SRG, including the ACLU’s New York affiliate, say the unit is inherently violent due to its counterterrorism specialization that they claim “suppress protesters” and disregards “focus on First Amendment protections.”

The training manual, reviewed by Fox News Digital, distinguishes between “peaceful/compliant” crowds and those deemed “violent/non-compliant.” It also identifies three categories of protesters: “everyday citizen,” “professional” and “anarchist.”

The first identifier under the “everyday citizen” protester immediately acknowledges that they are honoring their First Amendment right to organize.

FLORIDA EYES POACHING NYPD OFFICERS AFTER MAMDANI DISMANTLES ELITE UNIT

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/BIKE-MANUAL.jpg

The NYPD’s Special Response Group’s biking training manual identifies three categories of protesters: “everyday citizen,” “professional” and “anarchist.”(NYPD)

Despite the dismantling of the SRG, Mamdani’s plan would still likely require police officers be present at larger demonstrations. The new civilian-led group, however, would be there to attempt to de-escalate the protesters if it should show signs of turning violent.

Mamdani has not yet said when the civilian-led team will be established or take the streets. He also announced the creation of the First Amendment Support Team (FAST), a 30-officer NYPD unit, that will help deescalate crowds while the CDDD is being developed.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Chell, who has announced he will be running for mayor of New York City in 2029 when Mamdani would likely be seeking a second term, said he doubts the new team will take form until at least 2028 – if ever.

“What’s scary about all this, the mentality of how the mayor and his staff and his socialist friends want to run this city,” Chell said.

“If they get everything they want, we’re gonna be a third world city and I don’t know if we can ever get it back.”

Hannah is a Production Assistant for the Politics team at Fox News Digital.

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注

湘ICP备2026001899号-2