2026年11月19日 美国东部时间凌晨5点 / 福克斯新闻网
彼得·纳瓦罗的律师称,要求证明证人明知故犯将遏制被滥用的国会传票
作者:伊莱恩·马伦
特朗普助手彼得·纳瓦罗的最高法院之争可能会降低因拒执传票而监禁官员的难度
纳瓦罗的律师阿比·坎布利表示,胜诉判决将通过降低判定藐视国会罪名的难度,遏制国会传票的“武器化”。
NEW 你现在可以收听福克斯新闻网的文章了!
收听这篇文章
6分钟
一名因拒执国会传票而在联邦监狱服刑四个月的特朗普政府官员,正在向最高法院申请推翻对他的定罪,这起案件可能会提高其他拒绝配合国会要求的人被刑事起诉的门槛。
彼得·纳瓦罗在特朗普政府第一任期内担任高级贸易顾问,他于上个月向最高法院提交了请愿书。纳瓦罗目前在特朗普政府中担任贸易与制造业高级顾问。他在2023年因两项藐视国会罪名被定罪,罪名源于他以相信自己受行政特权保护为由,拒绝向民主党主导的众议院1月6日委员会提供证词和文件。
如果大法官们受理此案,他们可能会要求证明涉案人员明知自己违法,从而降低判定拒执国会传票罪名的难度。
法官驳回针对被指控就亨特·拜登调查向国会撒谎的前联邦调查局官员的案件
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/peter-navarro-2025.jpg
2025年7月7日,周一,在华盛顿特区白宫接受电视采访时,时任白宫贸易与制造业高级顾问的彼得·纳瓦罗(Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
在纳瓦罗审判前,美国地区法官阿米特·梅塔于2023年8月裁定,他未能证明特朗普政府就该传票主张了行政特权,因此禁止他以该理由作为辩护依据。服刑期满后,纳瓦罗就定罪判决向美国哥伦比亚特区联邦巡回上诉法院提起上诉,该法院裁定,即便一个人主观上误以为自己的拒执行为合法,拒执传票仍违反联邦法律。
由三名法官组成的合议庭裁定,只有总统才能依据第二条修正案主张行政特权,而特朗普从未赋予纳瓦罗该项保护。
“纳瓦罗博士甚至在看到传票之前就主张行政特权,拒绝交出文件、拒绝出席证词取证,也拒绝配合特别委员会协调其特权主张的努力,”法院指出。
“换句话说,法院不能仅仅采信被告关于总统主张了特权的说法,因为这么做会不当搅乱三权分立的界限。”
但纳瓦罗的代理律师阿比谢克·坎布利辩称,哥伦比亚特区联邦巡回上诉法院对该法案的解读存在偏差,他援引了1933年最高法院的“美国诉默多克案”判决,该判决称,纳税人出于真诚但错误的信念,认为宪法保护他拒绝回答调查人员问题的行为,这一因素将决定其行为是否属于“故意”。
“我们坚信我们在法律问题上的立场是正确的,因为国会制定这项法案时特意使用了‘故意’一词,没有任何理由认为该词在本案中的适用会与其他绝大多数案件不同,但如果我们胜诉,确实会产生淡化法律战与武器化的附加效果,”坎布利告诉福克斯新闻数字频道。
众议院曾投票以藐视国会罪名指控纳瓦罗,因其未能配合传票要求,但坎布利辩称,1月6日委员会绕过了通常用于解决行政分支官员相关争议的谈判程序。
白宫律师对民主党发出的强硬警告让双方法律专家对一项关键威胁存疑
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/robert-garcia_001.jpg
2026年11月10日,加州民主党众议员罗伯特·加西亚在华盛顿特区朗沃思众议院办公楼举行的众议院民主党党团会议外向媒体发表讲话(Aaron Schwartz/Getty Images)
“涉及行政分支官员时,通常有一个协调程序,即他们会就行政分支官员的出席条件谈判条款,之后再确定是否适用行政特权,”坎布利告诉福克斯新闻数字频道。“而1月6日委员会的做法是,大幅简化了大部分协调流程,直接将相关人员移送起诉和提起公诉。”
坎布利表示,如果最高法院作出有利于纳瓦罗的判决,将有助于“淡化”民主党控制参众两院后可能出现的武器化行为。
“如果我们胜诉,且必须证明涉案人员具备相应主观心态才能判定其违法并定罪入狱,那么针对藐视国会的起诉数量将会减少,因为此类案件的举证难度会大幅提升,”坎布利称。“结果将是,人们少有机会将国会传票用作武器,而非仅用于国会传统上受限制的合法立法目的。”
纳瓦罗的律师提交请愿书的一周前,密歇根州民主党参议员埃莉莎·斯洛特金呼吁调查特朗普政府涉嫌的腐败行为,称针对那些“助长”总统的案件可能会对考虑进入政府工作的年轻人产生“威慑效应”。
2026年中期选举民主党获胜后,议员们纷纷在社交媒体上誓言要调查特朗普政府官员,众议院监督委员会民主党首席成员、加州众议员罗伯特·加西亚在社交平台X上发文称“请律师”。不过,共和党仍控制参众两院,直至2027年1月民主党接掌。
“我们不能任由人们利用法律战和其他武器化手段伤害政治对手,所以我们认为这份请愿书将长期保护所有人,让我们的政治环境更健康,因为我们不再会不断试图将国会传票用作起诉他人的工具,”坎布利告诉福克斯新闻数字频道。
注册获取政治新闻通讯
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/steve-bannon.jpg
2025年9月3日,史蒂夫·班农在华盛顿特区举行的国家保守派会议上发言(Dominic Gwinn拍摄 / Middle East Images via AFP)
保守派律师、第三条项目创始人兼主席迈克·戴维斯表示,该项目已提交支持请愿书的法庭之友意见书,他称最高法院必须受理此案以终结“法律战”。
“民主党利用国会将彼得·纳瓦罗投入监狱,只因他真诚捍卫特朗普总统的行政特权,”戴维斯表示。“哥伦比亚特区联邦巡回上诉法院随后裁定,真诚并非藐视国会的免责事由,这就把每一张国会传票都变成了刑事陷阱,撕毁了平行分支之间两个多世纪的协商成果。”
点击此处下载福克斯新闻应用
纳瓦罗的请愿书是在最高法院撤销对史蒂夫·班农的判决之后提交的。这位前特朗普白宫战略家在2024年因拒执众议院1月6日委员会的传票,被控两项藐视国会罪名,服刑四个月。2026年4月,最高法院在司法部提出撤销其起诉的动议后,撤销了哥伦比亚特区联邦巡回上诉法院对他案件的判决,并将此案发回重审。
伊莱恩·马伦是福克斯新闻数字频道及福克斯商业频道的撰稿人,负责报道国家政治。
blob:https://www.foxnews.com/d5fe16c1-8206-4b0d-9659-eb974a91d65e
Supreme Court urged to defang ‘criminal trap’ that has sent Trump officials to prison
November 19, 2026 5:00am EST / Fox News
Peter Navarro’s lawyers say requiring proof a witness knowingly broke the law would curb weaponized congressional subpoenas
By Elaine Mallon
Trump aide Peter Navarro’s Supreme Court fight could make it harder to jail officials over subpoenas
Abhi Kambli, Navarro’s attorney, says a ruling in his favor could curb the ‘weaponization’ of congressional subpoenas by making contempt convictions harder to secure.
NEW You can now listen to Fox News articles!
Listen to this article
6 min
A Trump administration official who served four months in federal prison for defying a congressional subpoena is asking the Supreme Court to overturn his convictions in a case that could raise the bar for criminally prosecuting others who refuse to comply with Congress’s demands.
Peter Navarro, who was a senior trade advisor to President Donald Trump during his first administration, filed a petition with the Supreme Court last month. Navarro currently serves in the Trump administration as senior counselor for trade and manufacturing. He was convicted in 2023 on two counts of contempt of Congress stemming from his refusal to provide testimony and documents to the Democratic-led House Jan. 6 committee on the grounds that he believed he was barred by executive privilege.
If the justices take the case, they could make it harder to convict someone for defying a congressional subpoena by requiring proof that the person knew they were breaking the law.
JUDGE TOSSES CASE AGAINST EX-FBI OFFICIALS ACCUSED OF LYING TO CONGRESS ABOUT HUNTER BIDEN INVESTIGATION
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/peter-navarro-2025.jpg
Peter Navarro, White House senior counselor for trade and manufacturing, during a television interview at the White House in Washington, D.C., on Monday, July 7, 2025.(Al Drago/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
Before Navarro’s trial, U. S. District Judge Amit Mehta ruled in August 2023 that he had failed to establish that Trump invoked executive privilege for the subpoena, barring him from relying on that claim as a defense. After serving his sentence, Navarro appealed his conviction to the U. S. Court of Appeals for the D. C. Circuit, which ruled that a person violates federal law by refusing to comply with a subpoena “even if he subjectively and mistakenly believed his default was lawful. “
The three-judge panel ruled that only the president can invoke executive privilege under Article II, and Trump never granted Navarro protection.
“Dr. Navarro claimed executive privilege before even seeing the subpoena and refused to turn over documents, appear for his deposition, or engage with the Select Committee’s efforts to accommodate his privilege claim,” the court wrote.
“A court, in other words, cannot simply take a defendant at his word that the President invoked privilege because doing so would impermissibly tangle separation-of-powers lines.”
But Abhishek Kambli, counsel for Navarro, argued the D.C. Circuit misinterpreted the statute, pointing to United States v. Murdock, a 1933 Supreme Court ruling that a taxpayer’s sincere but mistaken belief that the Constitution protected his refusal to answer investigators’ questions mattered in determining whether he acted “willfully.”
“We absolutely believe that we are correct on the law on this, because Congress chose to use the word willful when it put this statute together, and there’s no reason to believe that willful applies any differently in this context than it has in just about every other one, but it would have the added effect of toning down lawfare and weaponization if we were to succeed,” Kambli told Fox News Digital.
The House voted to hold Navarro in contempt for failing to comply with a subpoena, but Kambli argued the Jan. 6 committee bypassed the negotiations traditionally used to resolve disputes involving executive branch officials.
WHITE HOUSE LAWYER’S HARDBALL WARNING TO DEMS HAS LEGAL EXPERTS ON BOTH SIDES QUESTIONING ONE KEY THREAT
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/robert-garcia_001.jpg
U.S. Rep. Robert Garcia, D-Calif., gives remarks to media outside the House Democratic Caucus meeting in the Longworth House Office Building on Nov. 10, 2026, in Washington, D.C.(Aaron Schwartz/Getty Images)
“When it comes to executive branch officials, there was an accommodation process where they would negotiate terms of the appearance of the witness that’s an executive branch official, and then determined whether executive privilege applies or not,” Kambli told Fox News Digital. “What happened with the J-6 committee is that they short-circuited a lot of that and sent people straight to getting prosecuted and indicted.”
Kambli said a Supreme Court ruling in Navarro’s favor could help “tone down the weaponization that could potentially occur” once Democrats take control of both chambers of Congress.
“What would happen is that if we were to win and the correct mental state is required to prove someone violated this law and get convicted and sent to jail, you would have fewer prosecutions for contempt of Congress because they’re going to be much harder to prove,” Kambli told Fox News Digital. “And what will happen is that there’s less of an opportunity to wield a congressional subpoena in a weaponized manner rather than just through a legitimate legislative purpose, which Congress is limited to traditionally.”
Navarro’s lawyers filed the petition a week before Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., called for an investigation of alleged Trump administration corruption, saying cases targeting those who “enabled” the president could send a “deterrence message” to young people considering administration jobs.
Following Democrats’ wins in the 2026 midterm elections, lawmakers took to social media to vow investigations into Trump officials, with House Oversight Committee ranking member Rep. Robert Garcia, D-Calif., posting on X, “LAWYER UP.” However, Republicans still control both chambers of Congress until Democrats take control in January 2027.
“We can’t keep this up where people are utilizing lawfare and other weaponization tactics to harm their political opponents, so we think that this petition would protect everyone in the long term and allow our politics to be better, because we’re not constantly trying to utilize congressional subpoenas as a way to indict people,” Kambli told Fox News Digital.
SIGN UP TO GET THE POLITICS NEWSLETTER
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/steve-bannon.jpg
Steve Bannon speaks at the National Conservatism Conference in Washington D.C., Sept. 3, 2025.(Photo by Dominic Gwinn / Middle East Images via AFP)
Mike Davis, a conservative lawyer and founder and president of the Article III Project, which filed an amicus brief supporting the petition, said the Supreme Court must take this case up to end “lawfare.”
“Democrats weaponized Congress to throw Peter Navarro in prison for standing up for President Trump’s executive privilege in good faith,” Davis said. “The D.C. Circuit then ruled that good faith is no defense to contempt of Congress, and that turns every congressional subpoena into a criminal trap. It tears up more than two centuries of negotiation between the co-equal branches.”
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
The petition from Navarro comes after the Supreme Court vacated the ruling against Steve Bannon. The former Trump White House strategist served four months in federal prison in 2024 after being convicted of two counts of contempt of Congress for defying a subpoena from the House Jan. 6 committee. In April 2026, the Supreme Court vacated the D.C. Circuit’s decision in his case and sent it back for further proceedings following the Justice Department’s motion to dismiss his indictment.
Elaine Mallon is a writer for Fox News Digital and Fox Business covering national politics.
blob:https://www.foxnews.com/d5fe16c1-8206-4b0d-9659-eb974a91d65e
发表回复