2026年11月19日 美国东部时间凌晨5点 / KFF健康新闻
中期选举前一周,十几名民主党参议员向10家健康保险公司首席执行官发送了措辞严厉的批评信。
信件质问这些保险公司为何配合他们所称的特朗普政府“可能违法”的行动——该行动导致76万名平价医疗法案(Affordable Care Act,简称ACA)参保者在8月底快速被取消医保覆盖。
随后民主党在选举中取得令人震惊的压倒性胜利,今年1月开始他们将掌控参众两院。权力更迭为这项调查注入了新的分量,调查由俄勒冈州参议员罗恩·怀登牵头,预计他明年将执掌权力强大的财政委员会;以及佛蒙特州独立参议员伯尼·桑德斯,预计他将执掌卫生、教育、劳工与养老金委员会。
“随着民主党将拥有传唤文件、举行听证会及调查 perceived 滥用或失误的权力,一些保险公司可能会认为这项调查比此前更关乎重大利益,”乔治城大学法学院健康政策与法律中心主任凯蒂·基思表示。
怀登的发言人泰勒·哈维在一封电子邮件中称:“怀登参议员将继续调查企业利益集团与特朗普政府之间剥夺美国民众医疗保障的秘密安排。参议院民主党人将动用一切可支配的工具寻求答案。”
新的监督能力
数月来,特朗普政府一直在推行这样的观点:从ACA到医疗补助(Medicaid)、临终关怀等政府卫生项目中欺诈行为猖獗,而只有共和党能遏制这种情况。白宫及一些共和党候选人利用这一观点试图反击民主党关于医保可负担性的竞选宣传。
特朗普政府的反欺诈行动仍在继续。8月的取消医保事件是政府更大规模行动的一部分,该行动旨在从奥巴马医改计划中移除拥有其他医保的人员,并更严格审查人们为获得保费补贴所提供的信息。法院已叫停政府的部分新规,包括针对某些低收入参保者提高收入核查要求,以及一项可能使多达1.9万名新代理人无法在当前年度开放 enrollment 期间协助人们注册的暂停令。不过,取消医保行动的第二阶段仍在审查另外41.9万名ACA参保者的资格。
此外,特朗普政府的新规要求开放 enrollment 期间注册的部分人员需接受额外的在线身份验证。10月时,保险公司收到相关指导,要求他们核查代理人和经纪人中的可疑模式,并在发现问题时采取包括削减佣金在内的措施。目前尚不清楚是否有保险公司采取了这些自愿步骤。
民主党参议员发给保险公司的信件揭示了新的多数党在持续调查政府ACA行动中可能采取的举措。
取消医保过程是否遵循了适当程序?多少合法参保者被退出名单?用于锁定这些参保者的标准——缺少社会保障号码或其他关键数据、未使用过医保、全额补贴却未回应推广行动——是否是判定欺诈的可靠指标?
“这些信件的语气凸显了这一过程的不透明程度,”乔治城大学的基思说。
不过政府官员为取消医保行动进行了辩护。
在10月14日的新闻发布会上,美国医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心(CMS)负责人梅赫梅特·奥兹被问及8月初的首轮取消医保事件。
“我们认为那是欺诈行为,”奥兹说,“那是保险经纪人创建、编造账户却不填写社会保障号码导致的结果。我们已确定这造成了76万个我们甚至无法联系到的‘幽灵账户’。我们打电话、发邮件、派信鸽都没人回应。”
今年早些时候,保险公司高层因医疗成本上涨接受质询后,被要求在11月6日前回应参议员关于取消医保行动的28个问题。该行动始于6月,当时政府要求保险公司联系被列为可疑对象的100多万名参保者。保险公司向CMS提交了在30天内未回复邮件、电话或信件的保单持有人名单。
参议员已向 Elevance Health、信诺(Cigna)、奥斯卡健康(Oscar Health)、AmeriHealth Caritas、Centene、佛罗里达蓝十字(Florida Blue)、医疗服务公司(Health Care Service Corporation)、Imperial Insurance Companies、Molina Healthcare 及联合健康集团(UnitedHealthcare)发送了信件。
截至11月10日,怀登办公室的哈维报告称收到了保险公司“不同程度的回应”。
接下来会发生什么?
很少有人否认ACA存在不当参保问题。政府表示,这类问题包括:注册时数据缺失或错误的情况;虚报收入以获取补贴的人员;“幽灵”参保者——要么不存在,要么不知道自己有医保的人;以及被违规呼叫中心或代理人注册以获取佣金的人员。
但关于这些问题的相对规模,以及监管机构遏制这些问题的措施,仍存在疑问。
“问题在于他们是否做得过头了,导致许多符合条件的人失去医保,”KFF的客座研究员、KFF健康新闻所属的健康信息非营利机构,以及右翼智囊团美国企业研究所的奇普·卡恩表示。“新国会将向他们施压,要求拿出确凿证据,明确说明做了什么、哪些人被退出了。”卡恩同时是营利性医院贸易协会美国医院联合会的前总裁兼首席执行官。
民主党参议员在信件中毫不含糊地表明了立场,称“共和党人正在利用欺诈虚假说法削弱ACA Marketplace,将更多美国人踢出医保体系。”
不过民主党若试图干预取消医保行动也会面临限制。
“由于ACA政策的取消是通过特朗普政府的行政权力而非立法进行的,除非民主党能找到可在总统否决下通过的立法解决方案,或成为更广泛预算协议的一部分,否则他们无法阻止政府以欺诈为由取消ACA政策,”北卡罗来纳大学教堂山分校教授、卫生政策专家乔纳森·奥伯兰德表示。
民主党已表示将快速行动,试图恢复2025年底到期的更为优厚的ACA补贴,这一努力将面临阻力。但即使尝试失败,也可能在政治上对选民产生积极影响,成为解决可负担性问题的举措。这些补贴旨在让ACA保费更易承担。
2026年的 Marketplace 参保人数约为1900万,较2025年的近2200万大幅下降。
保守派政策团体认为,新冠疫情期间推出的额外补贴助长了欺诈,因为这让更多人有资格获得全额补贴计划,并鼓励他们虚报收入以获取最大额度的税收抵免。他们指出,将月度保费降至0美元的高额补贴也为违规经纪人的非法注册提供了便利。
“如果补贴增加,加入零保费计划的人数增多,欺诈问题必然会加剧,”保守派帕拉贡健康研究所主席布莱恩·布莱斯表示,该研究所的报告称存在广泛的不当参保问题,有时依据的数据显示,越来越多的参保者未使用医保。
他批评了民主党议员的信件,预计国会最终会认定政府的取消医保行动包含足够的核查措施,以确保合法参保者未被卷入,若被卷入也可恢复资格。
CMS新闻办公室在发给KFF健康新闻的一封未署名电子邮件中表示,仅有极少数人——不到被取消医保人数的0.01%——联系联邦 Marketplace 申请恢复医保。该机构尚未公布关于取消医保的更多细节,包括所有失去医保的人是否知晓此事。
布莱斯坚信,最终“民主党人会意识到这是合乎常理的良好治理,转而关注其他问题。”
KFF健康新闻是制作健康问题深度报道的全国性新闻编辑室,也是KFF的核心运营项目之一。KFF是独立的健康政策研究、民调及新闻来源。
相关内容:
- 平价医疗法案(Affordable Care Act)
- 特朗普政府
- 医疗保健
https://youtu.be/OePiXMRNtUQ?si=m99ZzXS_rQ4FDtAM&t=37
Big win sets up Democrats to intensify probe of Trump’s Obamacare purge
November 19, 2026 / 5:00 AM EST / KFF Health News
A week before the midterm elections, a dozen Democratic senators sent harshly critical letters to 10 health insurance company CEOs.
Why, the letters asked, had those insurers cooperated with what they called a “potentially unlawful” Trump administration effort that resulted in the rapid cancellation of coveragefor 760,000 Affordable Care Act enrollees in late August?
Then came the Democrats’ stunning electoral sweep that, come January, will put them in control of both the House and Senate. The power shift lends new weight to the insurance investigation, led by Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden, who is expected to chair the powerful Finance Committee starting next year, and independent Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who is expected to chair the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee.
“Some insurers might view this inquiry as more high-stakes than before given that Democrats will have the power to subpoena documents, hold hearings, and otherwise investigate perceived abuses or missteps,” said Katie Keith, a director of the Center for Health Policy and the Law at the Georgetown University Law Center.
“Senator Wyden will continue investigating the secret arrangement between corporate interests and the Trump administration that has deprived Americans of their health care,” Wyden spokesperson Taylor Harvey said in an email. “Senate Democrats will use every tool at their disposal to get answers.”
New oversight muscle
For months, the administration has promoted the idea that fraud is rampant in government health programs — from the ACA to Medicaid and hospice — and that the Republican Party is the one to thwart it. The White House and some GOP candidates used this talking point to try to counter Democrats’ campaign messages about affordability.
The Trump administration’s anti-fraud efforts are ongoing. The August cancellations are part of a larger initiative by the administration to remove from Obamacare plans people who have other coverage and more strictly scrutinize the information people provide to qualify for premium subsidies. Courts blocked some of the administration’s new rules, including heightened income verification for certain low-income enrollees and a moratorium that would have kept up to 19,000 new agents from helping people sign up during the current annual open enrollment period. Ongoing, however, is scrutiny of an additional 419,000 ACA enrollments in a second phase of the cancellation operation.
Also, new Trump administration requirements compel some people signing up during open enrollment to undergo additional online identity proofing. Insurers were sent guidance in October asking them to look for suspicious patterns among agents and brokers and take action, including cutting commissions, if they found problems. It’s unclear if any insurers have taken those voluntary steps.
The letters from the Democratic senators to insurers provide a look at what the new majority could pursue in its ongoing inquiry into the administration’s ACA actions.
Were proper procedures followed for removing people? How many legitimate enrollees were kicked off the rolls? Did the criteria used to target those enrollments —lack of Social Security number or other key data, not having used medical coverage, a full subsidy without a response to outreach efforts — serve as reliable proxies for determining fraud?
“The tone of these letters underscores just how much of a black box this process was,” said Keith at Georgetown.
Administration officials, however, have defended the cancellation effort.
At an Oct. 14 press conference, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz was asked about the initial round of cancellations in late August.
“That is fraud, we believe,” Oz said. “That is insurance brokers creating, manufacturing accounts without putting Social Security numbers in and has resulted, we have already determined, in 760,000 phantom accounts that we can’t even get in touch with. We call, we write, we send carrier pigeons — like, no one answers.”
After some of their executives were grilled early in the year over rising healthcare costs, the insurers were given until Nov. 6 to respond to 28 questions from the senators about the cancellation effort, which began in June when they were asked to try to reach more than a million enrollees the administration targeted as suspicious. They handed back to CMS the names of policyholders who did not respond to emails, phone calls, or letters within 30 days.
The senators sent letters to Elevance Health, Cigna, Oscar Health, AmeriHealth Caritas, Centene, Florida Blue, Health Care Service Corporation, Imperial Insurance Companies, Molina Healthcare, and UnitedHealthcare.
By Nov. 10, Harvey in Wyden’s office reported “varying levels of responsiveness” from the insurers.
What happens next?
Few dispute that there are problems with improper ACA enrollment. This category includes, the administration says, sign-ups with missing or incorrect data; people who fudge their income estimates to get subsidies; “phantom” enrollees, meaning people who either don’t exist or don’t know they have coverage; and those signed up by rogue call centers or agents to garner commissions.
But there are questions about the relative scale of those problems and the steps by regulators to thwart them.
“The question is whether they overreached and set up a situation that led to many people who are eligible losing their coverage,” said Chip Kahn, a visiting fellow at KFF, a health information nonprofit that includes KFF Health News, and the American Enterprise Institute, a right-leaning think tank. “They will be pushed hard by the new Congress to come up with the goods in terms of making it crystal clear what’s been done, who has been dropped.” Kahn is also the former president and CEO of the Federation of American Hospitals, a trade association of for-profit hospitals.
The Democratic senators left no doubt about where they stand, saying in their letters that “Republicans are weaponizing fraud falsehoods in order to undercut the ACA Marketplace and kick even more Americans off their health care.”
But Democrats will face limits if they try to interfere with the purge.
“Because the cancellation of ACA policies came via executive authority from the Trump administration rather than legislation, they cannot stop the administration from invoking fraud to cancel ACA policies — unless they can find a legislative solution that can survive a presidential veto or is part of a broader budget agreement,” said Jonathan Oberlander, who teaches health policy at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill.
Democrats have said they will move quickly to try to restore the more generous ACA subsidies that expired at the end of 2025, an effort that will face headwinds. But even a failed attempt might play politically with voters as a move to address affordability concerns. The subsidies were designed to make ACA premiums more affordable.
Marketplace enrollment for 2026 is about 19 million people, down sharply from nearly 22 million in 2025.
Conservative policy groups maintain that the additional subsidies, put in place during the COVID-19 era, fueled fraud by allowing many more people to qualify for fully subsidized plans and encouraging them to fudge income estimates to qualify for the largest credits. Large subsidies that reduced monthly premium payments to $0, they argue, also provided cover for unauthorized sign-ups by rogue brokers.
“If the subsidies go up and there are more people in zero-premium plans, then absolutely there will be more fraud,” said Brian Blase, president of the conservative Paragon Health Institute, whose reportsassert widespread improper enrollments, sometimes basing that on data it says shows that a growing percentage of enrollees don’t use their insurance.
He’s critical of the Democrats’ letter and expects Congress will ultimately conclude that the administration’s cancellation effort included enough checks to ensure that legitimate enrollees were not caught up or, if they were, could be reinstated.
Very few people — fewer than 0.01% of those purged — have contacted the federal marketplace to request reinstatement, the CMS press office said in an unsigned email to KFF Health News. The agency has not released further details about the cancellations, including whether everyone who lost coverage is aware.
Blase is convinced that, eventually, “the Democrats will realize it was commonsense good governance and move on to something else.”
KFF Health Newsis a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF— the independent source for health policy research, polling, and journalism.
In:
- Affordable Care Act
- Trump Administration
- Healthcare
https://youtu.be/OePiXMRNtUQ?si=m99ZzXS_rQ4FDtAM&t=37
发表回复