最高法院驳回对马里兰州敏感场所限枪令的挑战


2026年11月16日 美国东部时间上午9:49 / CBS新闻

华盛顿讯——最高法院于周一驳回了针对马里兰州法律的诉讼挑战,该法律禁止在学校、公园及政府大楼等敏感场所携带枪支。

在驳回一群马里兰州居民及枪支权利组织的上诉时,最高法院维持了下级法院支持相关规定的裁决。

去年,最高法院裁定废除了夏威夷州的一项法律,该法律要求隐蔽携带枪支的许可持有者在将枪支带入对公众开放的私人财产前需获得许可。

本案争议的核心是马里兰州的一系列法律,这些法律限制在公共场所携带枪支的地点。该州禁止在校园、公共集会、公共交通系统,以及公园、博物馆和赌场携带枪支。

另一套限制性规定于2023年出台,此前最高法院在2022年作出具有里程碑意义的裁决,首次认定美国宪法第二修正案保护在住所外携带枪支的权利。根据新的限制措施,禁止在日托中心、医疗设施、政府大楼,或公众为“娱乐、教育活动或其他集体社交活动”而聚集的场所携带枪支。

在马里兰州最新限制措施签署成为法律的同一天,两组原告提起诉讼,声称这些措施违反了第二修正案。诉讼所涉场所共有10类。

这两起案件被合并审理,联邦地区法院拒绝阻止针对博物馆、医疗保健设施、公共交通系统、州立公园、娱乐场所、校园及政府大楼的限制措施。但地区法院在公共集会场所和现场酒类销售场所两项上作出了有利于原告的裁决。

美国联邦第四巡回上诉法院随后裁定,所有受到挑战的限制措施均符合第二修正案的规定。上诉法院采用了最高法院在2022年的裁决中提出的、用于评估枪支法规合宪性的新判定标准。根据这一标准,政府必须证明枪支限制措施符合国家的历史传统。

除了指出马里兰州部分法规的历史类似案例外,第四巡回上诉法院还称,最高法院曾在2008年和2010年的两项裁决中确认,禁止在政府大楼和校园携带枪支的法律是合法的。

马里兰州居民及枪支权利组织向最高法院提起上诉,称需要最高法院介入,帮助下级法院更清晰地界定公众持枪权的历史边界,因为越来越多的州正在制定针对特定场所的限枪措施。

他们在诉状中写道:“这些所谓‘敏感场所禁令’的合宪性,是最高法院2022年裁决后司法部门面临的最关键问题之一。如果像马里兰州所主张的以及下级第四巡回上诉法院所裁定的那样,‘在公共场所’持枪的权利并不包括政府拥有的公共场地,或正在开展受第一修正案保护的活动的场所,或人们就餐、饮酒或娱乐消遣的场所,那么就很难知晓‘在公共场所’持枪的权利实际保护的是什么。”

但马里兰州总检察长安东尼·布朗辩称,该州的敏感场所法律符合国家枪支管制的历史传统,因此合宪。他指出,美国有“悠久的历史传统”,禁止在某些特定场所携带枪支,包括那些“封闭且拥挤”的场所。

“本院曾认可在学校、立法机构、投票站及法院实施此类‘长期存在’的禁令,同时承认这一清单并非穷尽所有可能,”布朗在一份文件中写道。

自最高法院确立这一判定枪支法规合法性的新标准以来,多年来已面临多项针对长期现行枪支法律的挑战。2024年,最高法院维持了一项联邦法律,该法律禁止受到家庭暴力限制令约束的人持有枪支。

由首席大法官约翰·罗伯茨执笔的多数派意见中,8名大法官一致认为,依据其新的历史传统标准,“恰当的分析”是“考量受挑战的法规是否符合我们监管传统所依据的原则”。

随后,在上一个审理期,最高法院全票裁定,第二修正案不允许政府起诉偶尔吸食大麻的人。

分类:
美国最高法院
马里兰州
枪支法律

Supreme Court turns away challenge to Maryland restrictions on guns in sensitive places

November 16, 2026 / 9:49 AM EST / CBS News

Washington — The Supreme Court on Monday turned away a challenge to Maryland laws that prohibit firearms in sensitive places like schools, parks and government buildings.

In rejecting the appeal from a group of Maryland residents and gun rights groups, the high court leaves in place a lower court decision that upheld the rules.

The Supreme Court last year struck down a Hawaii law that required concealed-carry permit holders to receive permission before bringing their firearms onto private property open to the public.

At issue in the case were a set of Maryland laws that limit the places where guns can be carried in public. The state prohibits firearms from being brought on school property, at public demonstrations and on public transit, as well as in parks, museums and casinos.

Another set of limits was enacted in 2023, in the wake of the Supreme Court’s landmark 2022 decision that recognized for the first time that the Second Amendment protects the right to carry a gun outside the home. Under the new restrictions, people are prohibited from carrying firearms at daycare and medical facilities, government buildings or other places where the public gathers for “entertainment, educational enrichment or other collective social pursuits.”

On the same day Maryland’s latest restrictions were signed into law, two sets of plaintiffs filed lawsuits arguing they violated the Second Amendment. The suits targeted 10 categories of places.

The two cases were consolidated, and a federal district court declined to block the limits on museums, health care facilities, public transit, state parks, entertainment venues, school grounds and government buildings. But the district court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs as to public demonstrations and places that sell alcohol for on-site consumption.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 4th Circuit went on to rule that all of the challenged restrictions are consistent with the Second Amendment. The appeals court applied the Supreme Court’s new test for evaluating the constitutionality of gun regulations, which it laid out in its 2022 decision. Under that framework, the government must show that a firearms restriction is consistent with the nation’s historical tradition.

In addition to pointing to historical analogues of some of Maryland’s regulations, the 4th Circuit said the Supreme Court has twice, in decisions from 2008 and 2010, asserted that laws forbidding guns in government buildings and on school grounds are allowed.

The Maryland residents and gun rights groups appealed to the Supreme Court and argued that its intervention is needed to help lower courts better define the historical limits on the right to have guns in public as more and more states are enacting location-specific limits.

“The constitutionality of these so-called ‘sensitive place’ bans is among the most critical questions facing the judiciary in the wake of” the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision, they wrote in their petition. “If, as Maryland maintains and the Fourth Circuit below held, the right to carry a firearm ‘in public’ does not include public locations that are owned by the government, or where First Amendment protected activity is being carried out, or where people go to eat and to drink or gather for amusement and recreation, then it is hard to know what the right to carry a firearm ‘in public’ actually protects.”

But Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown argued that the state’s sensitive-place laws are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearms regulation, and therefore constitutional. He noted that there is a “rich American tradition” of barring guns in certain locations, including those that are “confined and crowded.”

“This Court endorsed such ‘longstanding’ bans in schools, legislative assemblies, polling places, and courthouses, while recognizing that this list was non-exhaustive,” Brown wrote in a filing.

In the years since the Supreme Court laid out its new test for determining the legality of gun regulations, it has been confronted with a number of challenges to longstanding firearms laws. In 2024, the Supreme Court upheld a federal law that prohibits people subject to domestic violence restraining orders from having guns.

In an opinion authored by Chief Justice John Roberts, the eight-justice majority said the “appropriate analysis” under its new historical tradition standard “involves considering whether the challenged regulation is consistent with the principles that underpin our regulatory tradition.”

Then, in its last term, a unanimous Supreme Court said the Second Amendment does not allow the government to prosecute a person who is an occasional marijuana user.

In:

Supreme Court of the United States
Maryland
Gun Laws

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注

湘ICP备2026001899号-2