索托马约尔大法官表示支持最高法院实行任期限制


作者:约翰·弗里策
发布时间:美国东部时间2026年11月20日下午4:42

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/2022-10-07t145705z-1907965629-rc27ww99objz-rtrmadp-3-usa-court.jpg
2022年10月7日,美国最高法院索尼娅·索托马约尔大法官。
埃夫elyn·霍克斯坦/路透社/档案照片

索尼娅·索托马约尔大法官周五在费城对听众表示,她可以支持最高法院大法官实行任期限制,这一议题的辩论可能会在明年民主党掌控国会后升温。

作为最高法院资深自由派大法官,索托马约尔指出,许多其他国家无需实行终身任职,就能让政治不干预本国司法体系。她先是告诉听众,自己不会对这一想法发表意见,随后又暗示自己愿意支持这一构想。

“就像生活中的其他事情一样,我对任期限制并不会感到不满,”索托马约尔在美国哲学学会主办的活动上表示。

围绕最高法院拟议结构性改革的讨论在民主党中期选举大获全胜后再度浮现。这场辩论大多来自保守派对那些存在多年的改革构想的警告。例如,塞缪尔·阿利托大法官在选举后多次强调司法独立的重要性,却未详细阐述相关提案。

索托马约尔在费城指出,任期限制是一个“正在被积极讨论的构想”。

民调显示,大法官任期限制获得了公众的大力支持,不过许多共和党人认为,任何对最高法院结构的改变都是在破坏司法独立。即便明年民主党掌控国会,这类措施也不太可能在参议院获得通过,或得到唐纳德·特朗普总统的支持。

此外,目前尚不清楚国会是否可以通过立法来设定任期限制,还是需要通过难度大得多的宪法修正案。

“尽管一项又一项民调显示,绝大多数自由派和保守派都支持最高法院实行任期限制,但我认为现任大法官中没有多数人支持这一构想,因此听到索托马约尔大法官似乎愿意支持这一想法,确实令人振奋,”监督最高法院的组织“纠正最高法院”的负责人加布·罗思表示。

“毕竟,”罗思说,“在民主制度下,任何人都不应在如此重要的职位上任职30或35年——这已成为常态,尤其是考虑到本世纪最高法院为自己攫取了不受约束的权力。”

索托马约尔的这番言论似乎超出了她2024年在苏黎世大学公开探讨这一想法时的表态。根据罗思的组织发布的音频,当时索托马约尔表示,该提案将防止最高法院的意识形态平衡“长期失衡”。

但她当时也指出,联邦大法官是被授予终身任职的,“这在宪法层面是不容剥夺的”。

索托马约尔周五的发言大多集中在回顾最高法院近期的重大裁决,包括关于出生公民权和总统豁免权的裁决。2022年转为资深法官的美国巡回法院法官戴维·塔特尔问索托马约尔,最高法院是否因为大多数大法官的职业道路相似而失去了某些特质。

“肯定如此,”索托马约尔说,“他们已经忘记了,每一起案件的核心都是人。”

Justice Sotomayor signals support for Supreme Court term limits

By John Fritze

Published Nov 20, 2026, 4:42 PM ET

https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/2022-10-07t145705z-1907965629-rc27ww99objz-rtrmadp-3-usa-court.jpg
US Supreme Court Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor on October 7, 2022.
Evelyn Hockstein/Reuters/File

Justice Sonia Sotomayor told an audience in Philadelphia on Friday that she could support term limits for members of the Supreme Court, treading into a debate that may pick up steam when Democrats take control of Congress next year.

Sotomayor, the court’s senior liberal justice, noted that many other nations have managed to keep politics out of their judiciaries without lifetime appointments. After telling an audience that she wouldn’t offer an opinion on the idea, she then hinted that she was open to supporting the idea.

“As with everything else in life, I wouldn’t be unhappy with term limits,” Sotomayor said at an event hosted by the American Philosophical Society.

The discussion around proposed structural changes at the Supreme Court has resurfaced after the Democratic rout in the midterm election. Much of that debate has come from conservatives warning against ideas that have existed for years. Justice Samuel Alito, for instance, has repeatedly stressed the importance of an independent judiciary since the election, without getting into details about proposals.

Sotomayor noted in Philadelphia that term limits were an idea “being kicked around very actively.”

Term limits for justices receive healthy support in public opinion polling, though many Republicans view any change to the Supreme Court’s structure as an effort to undermine the judiciary’s independence. Even with Democratic control next year, it’s unlikely such a measure would clear the Senate or win support from President Donald Trump.

It’s also far from clear whether Congress could impose term limits by enacting a law, or whether such a move would require a far-harder-to-achieve constitutional amendment.

“Even though poll after poll shows that most liberals and most conservatives support Supreme Court term limits, I don’t believe a majority of the current justices do, so it’s heartening to hear that Justice Sotomayor appears open to them,” said Gabe Roth, who leads the Supreme Court watchdog Fix the Court.

“After all,” Roth said, “no one in a democracy should serve for 30 or 35 years, as has become the norm, in a position of such power — especially given the unbridled authority the Supreme Court has arrogated to itself this century.”

Sotomayor’s remarks appeared to go beyond what she said during an appearance at the University of Zurich in 2024 in which she openly weighed the idea. During that appearance, according to audio posted by Roth’s group, Sotomayor said the proposal would keep the ideological balance of the court from being “skewed for too long.”

But then she also suggested that federal judges are promised the job for life and “that can’t be taken away constitutionally.”

Much of Sotomayor’s remarks on Friday were focused on looking back at recent high-profile decisions from the court, including on birthright citizenship and presidential immunity. US Circuit Judge David Tatel, who took senior status in 2022, asked Sotomayor if the high court had lost something because most of its justices had taken similar professional paths to the bench.

“For sure,” Sotomayor said. “They’ve forgotten that at the center of every case is people.”

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注

湘ICP备2026001899号-2