2026-11-20T18:09:10.220Z / CNN
据CNN获悉,一名美国国会资深民主党人警告称,如果特朗普政府和这位科技富豪拒绝披露是谁下令放缓乌克兰军用级“星链”卫星服务,立法者将扣留对埃隆·马斯克旗下SpaceX开发的系统的政府资金支持。
据CNN获取的一份机密通信摘录显示,民主党众议员吉姆·海姆斯将于明年1月出任众议院情报委员会主席,他在发给国家情报总监杰伊·克莱顿的机密函件中,要求澄清近几个月来多次导致乌克兰“星盾”连接速度放缓的原因。
“说白了,我们委员会无法为政府无法完全掌控的政府系统开发项目授权资金,”海姆斯在给克莱顿的信中写道,“感谢你协助获取此事的透明度,这样我们未来在为采用SpaceX作为主要供应商的系统开发项目授权资金时,才能有信心推进。”
这一警告发出之际,越来越多的民主党人誓言要调查乌克兰依赖其进行防御的“星盾”系统所受限制。经过两轮持续多日的速度限制后,谁该对此负责仍几乎没有明确说法。明年1月民主党掌控国会后,参众两院的民主党立法者均表示计划审查特朗普政府与俄罗斯的更广泛往来。
海姆斯决心调查这一放缓情况,正值泽连斯基近日表示“星盾”系统再次面临限制,而即便特朗普本周早些时候与普京会面后,乌克兰仍面临俄罗斯发动的大规模新攻势。
据CNN获取的另一份发给SpaceX首席执行官马斯克的信函显示,海姆斯还已正式请求与马斯克会面,讨论此次服务放缓问题。
“我对你的请求很明确:请解释2026年10月对‘星盾’服务做出的调整、做出这些调整的原因,以及这些调整是SpaceX单方面做出的,还是美国政府官员下达的指令,”海姆斯在给马斯克的信中写道。
“我已向政府高级官员传达过,我的看法是:SpaceX可能单方面修改美国政府合同,加上其对国会监督缺乏回应,这令人怀疑美国政府与SpaceX签订的每一项合同,包括你描述为‘归美国政府所有并由其管控’的独立军用级‘系统’的开发合同,”给马斯克的信函中这样写道。
CNN已联系SpaceX请其置评。
据一名熟悉海姆斯想法的消息人士透露,明年1月海姆斯就任众议院情报委员会主席后,他的首要任务之一将是调查马斯克对“星盾”等SpaceX系统的管控情况,必要时动用预算权力迫使该公司就此次服务放缓问题给出答案。
海姆斯可利用的最明显工具被称为“资金限制”,这使委员会能够在达到某些条件前,在年度《情报授权法》中依法限制某些项目的资金。
如果SpaceX和特朗普政府继续对立法者的要求置之不理,海姆斯还可与国会拨款委员合作,重新分配或阻止向SpaceX系统提供更多资金。
据海姆斯表示,发给克莱顿的机密函件和发给SpaceX的公开信函提出了两大核心关切:一是谁做出损害乌克兰国防的决策仍不明确;二是相关政府部门及SpaceX迄今对立法者提问的回应不足。
10月期间,上述限制已实施数周。本月早些时候,泽连斯基表示,在乌克兰被占领土上空已实施新的限制措施,目前这些限制已实施一周多。美国的乌克兰最高外交官丹尼斯·塞尼克周五告诉CNN,他们已与五角大楼取得联系,但尚未收到SpaceX的回应。
SpaceX拥有价值数十亿美元的美国政府太空系统合同,因此在国家安全领域扮演着至关重要的独特角色。这些合同是立法者施加影响力的筹码,但威胁限制SpaceX系统的资金支持存在风险——可能损害美国自身国防所依赖的不可替代资产。
特朗普政府、马斯克和SpaceX高管对是谁下令限制乌克兰“星盾”连接速度给出了不同说法,此举导致乌克兰军用互联网服务中断,并严重影响了发射导弹和无人机攻击、抵御俄罗斯打击的关键系统运作。
“星盾”最初出现问题是在10月中旬,当时特朗普政府以乌克兰袭击俄罗斯炼油厂为由威胁停止向基辅提供情报,同时特朗普达成协议购买俄罗斯柴油并放松对莫斯科的制裁。这位美国总统曾与乌克兰总统弗拉基米尔·泽连斯基发生争执,并暗示乌克兰应更换新领导人。
有关“星链”服务放缓的报道在白宫内部引发混乱,许多官员最初不确定美国政府是否扮演了任何角色,以及扮演了何种角色。
据CNN此前报道,一旦民主党掌控国会参议院,参议院外交关系委员会也计划调查“星盾”放缓问题。上周,该委员会即将卸任的民主党最高议员、即将出任主席的人士致信马斯克,要求他和SpaceX保存与此次服务中断相关的文件。
在特朗普公开抨击泽连斯基之前,其顾问已知道总统对泽连斯基不满,但他们并未听到总统讨论具体计划阻碍基辅袭击俄罗斯柴油炼油厂的能力——特朗普一直将全球能源价格上涨归咎于此。
特朗普告诉官员他想找出服务放缓的源头,后来他告诉记者自己没有直接参与这一决定。政府内部官员将此理解为彻查此事、调查系统如何被限制的指令。
一位熟悉相关讨论的消息人士告诉CNN,私下里,SpaceX高管和国防官员已向一些问询的立法者表示,10月限制服务的决定最初来自白宫,不过特朗普一再否认直接参与此事。
最终,特朗普政府高级官员似乎将责任归咎于私人企业SpaceX及其与乌克兰签订的“服务条款”。
据一名熟悉此事的消息人士透露,与乌克兰使用“星盾”能力相关的服务条款具体内容大多属于机密。
该消息人士补充道,但乌克兰等盟友共享这一能力是有条件和限制的,这意味着乌克兰使用“星盾”“非常依赖美国的许可”,特定合同条款会对此做出规定。
消息人士承认,五角大楼与SpaceX达成的“星盾”协议因“埃隆因素”变得复杂,指出马斯克在公司拥有的独特权威使其能够自上而下推动项目变更。
但该消息人士补充道,“星盾”仍然是一个由政府管理的应用项目。
“SpaceX代表美国政府运营它,但美国政府完全掌控着任务分配、使用方式以及准入权限,”他们说。
“‘星盾’是五角大楼的系统,”另一名美国官方消息人士也强调,明确区分了SpaceX在管理军用级卫星系统方面的角色与其商业版“星链”的运营方式。
然而,一名五角大楼官员告诉CNN,国防部长皮特·赫格塞思未参与此次服务放缓,也事先毫不知情——这进一步引发了最终责任人是谁的疑问。
“他不知道这件事正在发生,”谈及赫格塞思时这名官员表示。
服务放缓事件发生后不久,一些特朗普政府官员开始指责马斯克,称他“独断专行”采取单边行动。一名美国高级官员当时告诉CNN,特朗普从未要求限制“星盾”服务。
“埃隆是单方面行事,”另一名美国官员此前坚称。
两党立法者都对马斯克可能利用其对“星盾”等政府管理系统前所未有的权力,单方面代表美国制定外交政策的前景表示担忧。
民主党和共和党立法者都呼吁五角大楼监察长调查此次服务放缓,以及该事件与早期导弹预警问题是否会使美国人员面临风险,但五角大楼监察长拒绝了这一请求,指示立法者向相关军种部门提问。
“最终情况可能是严重损害活动并违反五角大楼合同,也有可能是SpaceX做出了有权采取的行动但未向任何人发出任何警告,”海姆斯本周在接受CNN采访时表示。
“但我们会查清真相。此事事关重大,”他补充道。
在给马斯克的信中,海姆斯强调,如果这位科技富豪拒绝提供答案,美国政府对SpaceX所有系统的资金授权都将面临风险。
“在收到我关于乌克兰‘星盾’服务相关问题的满意答复前,我难以继续支持为SpaceX开发的这些政府所有系统授权资金,”他在给马斯克的信中写道。
Trump intel chief warned no funding for Musk’s SpaceX without answers on Ukraine Starshield slowdown
2026-11-20T18:09:10.220Z / CNN
A top Congressional Democrat is warning that lawmakers will withhold government funding for systems developed by Elon Musk’s SpaceX if the Trump administration and tech billionaire refuse to disclose who is responsible for ordering the slowdown of Ukraine’s military-grade Starlink satellite service, CNN has learned.
In a classified communication sent to Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton, Democratic Rep. Jim Himes — who will become chairman of the House Intelligence Committee in January — demanded clarity on what led to the slowdown of Ukraine’s Starshield connection speed on multiple occasions in recent months, according to an excerpt of the communication obtained by CNN.
“Simply, our committee cannot authorize funds for the development of government systems that the government will not fully control,” Himes wrote to Clayton. “I appreciate your assistance in obtaining transparency in this instance so we can have confidence going forward in authorizing funding for the development of systems using SpaceX as the primary vendor.”
The warning comes as a growing number of Democrats have vowed to investigate the limits on Ukraine’s Starshield system, which Ukraine relies on for its defenses. After two rounds of days-long speed restrictions, there has been little clarity on who is responsible. Democratic lawmakers in both the House and Senate have said they plan to scrutinize the Trump administration’s broader dealings with Russia when the party takes control of Congress in January.
Himes’ determination to investigation the slowdown comes as Zelensky has said in recent days that the Starshield system is facing limits once again, while Ukraine is facing massive renewed attacks from Russia even after Trump met with Putin earlier this week.
Himes has also formally requested a meeting with Musk to discuss the slowdown, according to a separate letter sent to the SpaceX CEO obtained by CNN.
“My ask to you is straightforward. Explain the changes that were made to the Starshield service in October 2026, why those changes were made and whether those changes were made unilaterally by SpaceX or were directed by a US government official,” Himes wrote to Musk.
“My view, which I have conveyed to senior Administration officials, is that SpaceX’s potentially unilateral modification of a US government contract, combined with its lack of responsiveness to congressional oversight, calls into question every contract the US government has with SpaceX, including the development of what you describe as the separate military-grade ‘systems owned and controlled by the US government,’” the letter to Musk states.
CNN has reached out to SpaceX for comment.
When Himes becomes chairman of the House Intelligence Committee in January, one of his top priorities will be investigating Musk’s control over SpaceX systems like Starshield and, if needed, leverage the power of the purse to extract answers from the company about the slowdown, according to a source familiar with his thinking.
The most obvious tool at Himes’ disposal for doing so is known as “ring fencing,” which allows the committee to legally restrict funding for certain projects in the annual Intelligence Authorization Act until certain conditions are met.
Himes could also work with congressional appropriators to redirect or block additional funding for SpaceX systems if the company and Trump administration continue to stonewall lawmakers.
According to Himes, the classified message to Clayton and the public letter sent to SpaceX raise two primary concerns: a lack of clarity around who made decisions that impeded Ukraine’s defense, and the lack of responsiveness from relevant government entities, as well as SpaceX, to questions from lawmakers to date.
The limitations were in place for several weeks in October. Earlier this month, Zelensky said that renewed limitations were in effect over the occupied territories of Ukraine. Those restrictions have now been in place for more than a week. Denys Sienik, Ukraine’s top diplomat in the US, told CNN Friday that they are in touch with the Pentagon but have received no response from SpaceX.
SpaceX maintains billions of dollars in US government contracts for space-based systems, occupying a uniquely critical role in national security as a result. Those contracts are a source of leverage for lawmakers but following through on any threat to restrict funding for SpaceX systems carries the risk of compromising irreplaceable assets the US relies on for its own national defense.
The Trump administration, Musk and SpaceX executives have offered various accounts of who authorized the throttling of Ukraine’s Starshield connection speed, a move that led to the disruption of its military internet service and slowed down a critical system for launching missile and drone attacks, as well as defending against Russian strikes.
The initial issues with Starshield were discovered in mid-October after the Trump administration threatened to withhold intelligence to Kyiv over its strikes on Russian refineries and after Trump made a deal to buy Russian diesel and ease sanctions on Moscow. The US president had sparred with President Volodymyr Zelensky and suggested Ukraine should get a new leader.
Reports about that slowdown in the Starlink service led to confusion inside the White House, where many officials were initially unsure what, if any, role the US government had played.
The Senate Foreign Relations Committee is also planning to investigate the Starshield slowdown once Democrats assume the majority in Congress, CNN previously reported. Last week, the outgoing top Democrat and incoming chair of the committee sent a letter to Musk demanding that he and SpaceX preserve documents related to the disruptions.
While Trump advisers were aware of his frustrations with Zelensky before he lashed out publicly, they had not heard the president discuss specific plans to hamper Kyiv’s ability to strike Russian diesel refineries, which he has blamed on rising global energy prices.
Trump told officials he wanted to find out where the slowdown originated and would later tell reporters he wasn’t personally involved in the decision. Officials inside the administration understood that as a directive to investigate the matter and look into how the system was slowed down.
Privately, SpaceX executives and defense officials have told some inquiring lawmakers that the decision to initiate the slowdown in October originally came from the White House, a source familiar with those discussions told CNN, though Trump has repeatedly denied any direct involvement.
Ultimately, top Trump officials appeared to put responsibility on the privately owned SpaceX and its “terms of service” with Ukraine.
The exact nature of those terms of service as they relate to Ukraine’s ability to use Starshield are largely classified, according to a source familiar with the matter.
But there are conditions and caveats for allies like Ukraine to share the capability, meaning Ukraine’s use of Starshield is “very dependent upon the US saying yes” with specific contract clauses that allow them to do it, the source added.
The Pentagon’s arrangement with SpaceX for Starshield is complicated by the “Elon factor,” the source acknowledged, pointing to Musk’s unique level of authority at the company allowing him to dictate program changes from the top down.
But Starshield is still a government-managed application, the source added.
“SpaceX flies it on behalf of the of the U.S. government, but the U.S. government is completely in control of how it gets tasked, how it gets used, who gets access to it,” they said.
“Starshield is a Pentagon system,” one of the sources, a US official, also reiterated, drawing a distinction between SpaceX’s role in managing the military-grade satellite system compared to how the company operates its commercially available version, known as Starlink.
Yet a Pentagon official told CNN that Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth had no involvement or foreknowledge of the slowdown – raising further questions about who was ultimately responsible.
“He had no idea it was happening,” the official said, referring to Hegseth.
In the immediate aftermath of the slowdown, some Trump officials began pointing the finger at Musk, saying he “went rogue” and acted unilaterally. Trump made no such request to throttle Starshield, one senior US official told CNN at the time.
“Elon did it unilaterally,” another US official previously insisted.
Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle have raised concerns about the prospect of Musk using his seemingly unprecedented powers over government-managed systems, like Starshield, to unilaterally enact foreign policy on behalf of the US.
Both Democratic and Republican lawmakers had called for a Pentagon watchdog investigation into the slowdown and whether it, in combination with issues in early missile warnings, put American personnel at risk. But that request was declined by the Pentagon Inspector General who instructed lawmakers to direct their questions to the relevant military service branches.
“There is an outcome where it was actually really bad activity and contravention of a Pentagon contract or maybe (SpaceX) did something they were entitled to do but just did not give anybody any warning,” Himes told CNN in an interview this week.
“But we are going to get to the bottom of it. There is a lot at stake here,” he added.
In his letter to Musk, Himes stresses that the authorization of US government funding for all SpaceX systems is at risk if the tech billionaire refuses to provide answers.
“It is difficult for me to continue supporting the authorization of funding for these SpaceX-developed, government-owned systems, until I receive satisfactory answers to my questions about the Starshield service in Ukraine,” he wrote to Musk.
发表回复