分析:戴维斯·温基
发布时间:2026年11月19日 美国东部时间下午6:43 / 美国有线电视新闻网(CNN)
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/gettyimages-2305274725.jpg
俄罗斯总统弗拉基米尔·普京、中国领导人习近平和美国总统唐纳德·特朗普出席11月19日在中国深圳麒麟山庄举行的三方会晤。
道格·米尔斯/ Pool /盖蒂图片社
美国总统唐纳德·特朗普、中国领导人习近平与俄罗斯总统普京本周举行的这场具有历史意义的三方峰会,可能并未立即取得显著的外交进展。
但在三国领导人联合声明中,有一句话本身就承载着历史底蕴——“核战争是无法打赢的,绝对不能发动。”
这句话最初是美国前总统罗纳德·里根在1982年向全国发表的讲话中提出的,1985年,里根与苏联领导人米哈伊尔·戈尔巴乔夫在日内瓦峰会后的联合声明中加入这句话后,其重要性随之提升。
几十年来,这句话被称为“里根-戈尔巴乔夫原则”。
这两位冷战时期的领导人将这一原则带入了1986年10月在冰岛雷克雅未克举行的会晤。解密文件显示,他们当时一致同意要削减各自的核武库,但后来因导弹防御问题产生的分歧导致谈判破裂。
尽管当时这场峰会看似失败,但在随后几年里,美国与苏联(及俄罗斯)最终达成了两项军控协议,废除了一类核武器,并推动双方削减了更大规模的核武器数量。
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/138yip2026main.jpg
11月19日,在中国南部广东省深圳市,中国国家主席习近平、美国总统唐纳德·特朗普与俄罗斯总统普京在亚太经济合作组织(APEC)峰会间隙出席麒麟山庄举行的三方会晤。
曼德尔·恩甘/法新社/盖蒂图片社
原子弹制造者J·罗伯特·奥本海默的孙子查尔斯·奥本海默提到了这一历史先例,他告诉CNN,他希望三国领导人在本周峰会上建立的“人际纽带”能预示未来将有相关政策工作来降低核战争风险。
奥本海默最近参加了纪念里根-戈尔巴乔夫峰会40周年的活动,他强调“雷克雅未克峰会在当时看来是多么失败”。
“但从历史的后见之明来看……我们知道,那次会晤后来推动了军控领域最富有成效的时期,”奥本海默说。
编剧、导演兼制片人迈克尔·罗素·冈恩曾创作、执导并制作了以雷克雅未克谈判为核心的剧集《战争边缘》。他表示,对支撑1986年会晤的核心理念的重申,为近年来冷战时期军控协议到期后的时代带来了“希望”的信号。
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/c37435-18.jpg
1986年10月12日,罗纳德·里根总统与米哈伊尔·戈尔巴乔夫在冰岛雷克雅未克峰会期间访问冰岛时,于 Höfði 宅邸留下的合影。
美国国家档案和记录管理局
核风险 reduction(此处保留专业表述)领域的专家对此次峰会能否取得突破则较为谨慎。雷克雅未克峰会之前曾有日内瓦峰会和密集的书面谈判铺垫,而本周的三方会晤是此类会晤的首次举行。
卡内基国际和平基金会研究核武器政策的高级研究员赵 Tong(此处为音译)告诉CNN,对里根-戈尔巴乔夫原则的联合重申“聊胜于无”。
但他认为,本周的这份声明“更多反映了当今三个主要核大国之间缺乏共识,而非它们共同利益的范围”。
在特朗普、普京与习近平的联合声明中,唯一的另一项核承诺是“就降低核风险和防止核武器扩散开展对话”。
不过,这位卡内基的专家强调,降低核风险并不意味着相关国家一定会“遏制其核军备竞赛”。赵 Tong 补充说,领导人并未提及使用核威胁来胁迫其他国家的问题。
尽管如此,奥本海默认为,此次会晤仍应为那些希望看到核武器得到管控的人们带来“新的希望”。特朗普和习近平过去都曾公开表示希望消除此类武器,如今已经有了开启谈判的途径。
后续核谈判的日期尚未确定,但据一位美国政府高级官员透露,预计美方代表团将由国务院牵头。
CNN记者凯莉·阿特伍德对本文有贡献。
戴维斯·温基在CNN的工作得到了奥特里德基金会(Outrider Foundation)和新闻资助伙伴(Journalism Funding Partners,JFP)的合作支持。CNN保留报道的完全编辑控制权。
Trump, Putin, Xi nukes statement echoes Reagan and Gorbachev — but will their actions?
Analysis by Davis Winkie
PUBLISHED Nov 19, 2026, 6:43 PM ET / CNN
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/gettyimages-2305274725.jpg
Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese leader Xi Jinping and U.S. President Donald Trump participate in a trilateral meeting at the Kylin Villa on November 19 in Shenzhen, China.
Doug Mills/Pool/Getty Images
The historic three-way summit between US President Donald Trump, Chinese leader Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin this week may have yielded little immediate diplomatic progress.
But one of the phrases in the leaders’ joint statement — “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought” — carries a historical legacy of its own.
First uttered by former President Ronald Reagan in a 1982 address to the nation, the phrase gained significance in 1985 when Reagan and Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev included it in a joint statement they made after a summit in Geneva.
The phrase became known as the Reagan-Gorbachev principle in subsequent decades.
The two Cold War leaders carried the principle into their October 1986 meeting in Reykjavik, Iceland, where declassified documents show they agreed to eliminate their respective nuclear arsenals before a dispute over missile defense led to the collapse of those negotiations.
Despite the summit’s seeming failure at the time, the US and the Soviet Union/Russia finalized a pair of arms control agreements in subsequent years that got rid of a category of nuclear weapons and forced a mutual reduction in the number of larger nuclear weapons.
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/138yip2026main.jpg
Chinese leader Xi Jinping, US President Donald Trump and Russia’s President Vladimir Putin take part in a trilateral meeting at Kylin Villa on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Summit in Shenzhen, in China’s southern Guangdong Province, on November 19.
Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images
Charles Oppenheimer, grandson of atomic bomb creator J. Robert Oppenheimer, pointed to that historical precedent and told CNN that he hopes the “human connection” formed between the three world leaders during this week’s summit will portend policy work in the future to reduce the risk of nuclear war.
Oppenheimer, who recently attended an event commemorating the 40th anniversary of the Reagan-Gorbachev summit, emphasized “how much of a failure (Reykjavik) seemed at the time.”
“But we kind of know with historical hindsight … that led on to the most productive period of arms control,” Oppenheimer argued.
Filmmaker Michael Russell Gunn, who wrote, directed and produced The Brink of War, a drama centered on the Reykjavik negotiations, said the reaffirmation of the mantra that undergirded the 1986 meeting offers a sign of “hope” after the expiration of the Cold War-era arms control agreements in recent years.
https://news-multimedia-1393112320.cos.ap-guangzhou.myqcloud.com/c37435-18.jpg
President Ronald Reagan with Mikhail Gorbachev at the Höfði House during their trip to Iceland for the Reykjavík Summit on October 12, 1986.
US National Archives and Records Administration
Experts in nuclear risk reduction are less optimistic that a breakthrough is on the horizon this time. Reykjavik was preceded by the Geneva summit and intensive written negotiations, whereas this week’s trilateral meeting was the first of its kind.
Tong Zhao, a senior fellow studying nuclear weapons policy at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, told CNN the joint reaffirmation of the Reagan-Gorbachev principle “is better than nothing.”
But Zhao argued that this week’s declaration “says more about how little common ground exists among the three leading nuclear powers today than about the extent of their shared interests.”
The only other nuclear commitment in the Trump-Putin-Xi joint statement was to “conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons.”
The Carnegie expert emphasized, however, that reducing nuclear risk doesn’t mean the countries will necessarily “restrain their nuclear arms competition.” The leaders did not address the use of nuclear threats to coerce other countries, Zhao added.
Oppenheimer argued that the meeting should nonetheless be a source of “renewed hope” for those who wish to see nuclear weapons reined in. Trump and Xi have publicly stated their desire to eliminate such weapons in the past, and now there is a path for negotiations to begin.
There is no date yet established for the follow-up nuclear talks, but it is expected that the US delegation will be led by the State Department, according to a senior administration official.
CNN’s Kylie Atwood contributed to this report.
_Davis Winkie’s work at CNN is supported by a partnership between_Outrider Foundation_and Journalism Funding Partners (JFP). CNN retains full editorial control of the reporting._
发表回复