特朗普强行推动本党重新划分选区 成效适得其反?


2026-11-16T10:00:16.829Z / 美国有线电视新闻网(CNN)

唐纳德·特朗普总统去年在得克萨斯州发起其大胆的十年中期选区重划策略时,自信地宣称共和党在“孤星之州(得克萨斯州别名)理应再获5个席位”。

当然,共和党本就没什么应得之说。中期选举已然给出了明确的现实教训。

在上周的选举中,共和党输掉了去年为自身操纵的得克萨斯州5个选区中的4个。但问题不止出在得克萨斯州。根据CNN的选区重划追踪数据,共和党仅在他们试图操纵的15个选区中赢得了2个。路易斯安那州还有1个席位将进入决胜选举。

总体而言,这一策略实则让共和党损失了席位——北卡罗来纳州重划后的选区将本党选民过于分散,使得民主党成功夺下至少6个共和党席位。民主党凭借自身的重划方案,在加利福尼亚州也赢得了少量额外席位。

主流观点认为,特朗普的选区重划策略对共和党造成了重大反效果。尽管2026年该策略确实付出了代价,但现在就说它不会对共和党长期有利还为时过早。

何以如此?选区重划之战的下一步将走向何方?

我们仍在等待部分选举结果,且在计算重划选区的得失时存在一定主观性,但目前显然能看出,共和党因这一策略实际损失了席位。

共和党在得克萨斯州和田纳西州各赢得1个席位。但民主党将在加利福尼亚州夺下5个席位,在北卡罗来纳州夺下6至7个席位,在俄亥俄州夺下3个席位。他们还拿下了得克萨斯州的2个共和党选区,且在田纳西州1个选区中领先,而该选区是共和党为让另一个选区更具胜算而刻意稀释的。

总体来看,共和党为自身重划了15个选区,而民主党仅重划了5个。但如果当前结果不变,民主党或可在这场选区重划之争涉及的各州净增16个席位。
(民主党还通过法院指令对犹他州选区进行重划,因此赢得了该州1个席位。)

北卡罗来纳州是“傻瓜曼德”;佛罗里达州和得克萨斯州则不然

自选举以来,人们热议所有这些选区划分方案如何让共和党自食恶果。但严格来说,并非完全如此。

北卡罗来纳州的情况显然适得其反——至少在本次选举和国会层面是如此,但佛罗里达州和得克萨斯州的其他选区划分方案只是未能达到共和党的预期。

佛罗里达州和得克萨斯州的共和党并非因重划选区而丢失席位;他们只是未能拿下原本期望的那些选区。

尽管输掉了全州级别的所有竞选,共和党仍赢得了得克萨斯州63%的选区。尽管全州竞争激烈,共和党仍赢得了佛罗里达州71%的选区。

有一个术语专门指代“不公正选区划分”产生反效果的情况——即过度分散己方选民,让对方拿下大量选区,这种情况被称为“傻瓜曼德”(dummymander)。而这种情况只在北卡罗来纳州真正出现。

地方共和党人从特朗普和共和党手中“救下”更多席位

但出人意料的是,那些拒绝追随特朗普这一策略的地方共和党人,实际上帮共和党在本次选举中避免了更大损失。

根据Decision Desk HQ的分析,共和党试图重划的选区本可能让南卡罗来纳州新增1个选区以及印第安纳州新增6个选区陷入危险——这可能导致共和党在印第安纳州遭遇全面溃败。

特朗普对投票反对这些选区方案的共和党州议员极为不满,在初选中针对并罢免了多名印第安纳州议员。

事实证明,这些议员其实是在帮他的忙,他们阻止了另外两个“傻瓜曼德”的出现。

但即便涉及这些在2026年失败甚至产生反效果的选区方案,也需要从长远角度来看待。

它们此次未能奏效甚至造成损害,并不意味着永远如此,也不代表整个策略会全盘失败。

完全有可能——甚至很有可能——在2028年和2030年的势均力敌的选举中,共和党会赢回北卡罗来纳州的多个席位,并拿下更多原本瞄准的阿拉巴马州、佛罗里达州、俄亥俄州和得克萨斯州的席位。毕竟,很多这类选区的特朗普得票率都达到了两位数。

如果确实如此,共和党最终将从这一过程中赢得不少席位。

该党或许会宣称这一切是值得的。毕竟,民主党目前赢得的席位,基本意味着本已庞大的民主党多数党优势将再增加约11席——从目前的约250席对185席,变为约260席对175席。

从当前情况来看,选区重划使得众议院选区的中位得票率向右转了约2个百分点——也就是说,这个选区在2024年的得票率,特朗普以约5个百分点的优势获胜,而非此前的3个百分点。

这不足以抵御民主党半个世纪以来最大的普选胜利,但长远来看仍会有很大帮助。

前提是事态维持现状。

但新近掌权的州级民主党人可能会延续共和党开启的进程,通过进一步重划选区,让整个选区格局更趋向长期平衡。

此前,民主党在马里兰州、纽约州和弗吉尼亚州重划选区时遭遇法律障碍,现在他们或可在2028年选举前推进重划,有望在这些州为自身赢得大量新席位。

民主党还可能在刚刚掌控“三权合一”的州(即州长职位及参众两院均由其控制)绘制新的选区。威斯康星州当选州长戴维·克劳利已表示将签署一项重划该州国会选区的法案。明尼苏达州也可能出现类似情况。

共和党则几乎没有更多机会重划更多选区。

民主党重回重划选区的政治风险可能很大,但显然是共和党先挑起这一切的,而且为自身划分了更多选区。

如果民主党不抓住仅有的机会,整个选区重划的过程最终仍可能让共和党受益——尽管这显然没给极力推动此事的特朗普本人带来多少好处。

Trump aggressively pushed his party to redraw electoral maps. How much did that backfire?

2026-11-16T10:00:16.829Z / CNN

When President Donald Trump launched his brazen mid-decade redistricting gambit in Texas last year, he confidently declared that Republicans were “entitled to five more seats” in the Lone Star State.

Of course, the GOP wasn’t entitled to anything. And the midterms offered a swift reality check.

In last week’s election, the party lost 4 of the 5 Texas seats it gerrymandered for itself last year. But it wasn’t just Texas. Republicans have won only 2 of the 15 districts they tried to rig for themselves, according to CNN’s redistricting tracker. One more seat, in Louisiana, is going to a runoff.

And all told, the gambit actually cost them seats, after the map they redrew in North Carolina spread the party too thin and allowed Democrats to flip at least a half-dozen GOP seats. Democrats were also able to win a handful of additional seats in California when they fought back with their own redraw.

There’s a prevailing narrative that Trump’s redistricting gambit backfired on the GOP — and pretty badly. But while there’s no question the plot was costly in 2026, it’s too early to say it won’t help Republicans over the long term.

How could that be? And what’s next in the redistricting battles?

We’re still waiting for some results — and there’s some subjectivity involved in how you count wins and losses when it comes to redistricted seats — but right now it’s clear Republicans actually lost seats from the ploy.

The GOP gained one seat in Texas and another in Tennessee. But Democrats are set to flip five seats in California, six or seven in North Carolina and three in Ohio. They also flipped two GOP districts in Texas and they have a narrow lead in a district in Tennessee that Republicans diluted to make another district more winnable.

So, all told, Republicans redrew 15 districts for themselves, compared to just five for Democrats. But if current results hold, Democrats could gain a net of 16 seats from the states that were redrawn in this redistricting fight.

(Democrats also gained a seat in Utah, due to a court-ordered redraw of that state’s map.)

North Carolina was a ‘dummymander’; Florida and Texas were not

There has been plenty of talk since the election about how all of these maps backfired on Republicans. But that’s not strictly true.

North Carolina clearly backfired — at least in this election and at the congressional level — but other maps like Florida’s and Texas’ merely failed to live up to GOP hopes.

Republicans didn’t lose seats in Florida and Texas because they redrew the maps; they just didn’t win the ones they’d hoped.

Republicans still won 63% of Texas’ districts despite losing every statewide race. And in Florida, Republicans still won 71% of the districts even though the statewide contests were close.

There is a term for when a gerrymander backfires by spreading your voters too thin and allowing the other party to win a bunch of districts: a “dummymander.” That really only happened in North Carolina.

Local Republicans saved Trump and the GOP from losing even more seats

But in a twist, local Republicans that declined to go along with Trump’s gambit actually saved the GOP from itself in this election.

According to an analysis from Decision Desk HQ, attempted Republican redraws could’ve jeopardized an additional district in South Carolina and six more in Indiana — leading to a potential wipeout in the Hoosier State.

Trump was furious with GOP state senators who voted against these maps. He targeted and unseated a number of Indiana state legislators in the primaries.

It turned out they were doing him a favor. They prevented two more dummymanders.

But even when it comes to these maps that failed or even backfired in 2026, it’s worth taking the long view.

Just because they didn’t work or even hurt this time doesn’t mean it will always be thus, or that the whole thing will have been a bust.

It’s quite possible — even likely — that in closer elections in 2028 and 2030, Republicans would win back many of those seats in North Carolina and pick off more of the ones they aimed for in Alabama, Florida, Ohio and Texas. A lot of these districts favored Trump by double-digits, after all.

If that does happen, the GOP would have gained a fair amount of seats from this process, in the end.

And the party would probably declare that to be worth it. After all, the current Democratic gains basically just mean the already-huge new Democratic majority will be about 11 seats bigger — around 260-175 instead of around 250-185 seats.

As things stand, the redistricting process moved the median House district about two points to the right — so that it’s a district Trump won by about five points in 2024, rather than by three points.

That wasn’t enough to withstand the Democrats’ biggest popular vote win in half a century, but it should still help plenty long term.

That’s if things stay where they are.

But the newly empowered state-level Democrats could finish what Republicans started by redrawing some more maps — and bringing this whole process something closer to long-term parity.

After previously facing legal obstacles to redrawing maps in Maryland, New York and Virginia, Democrats could move forward with redraws ahead of the 2028 election that could hand them a significant number of new seats in those states.

Democrats could also draw new maps in states where they just landed “trifectas” of control — the governorship and both chambers of the state legislature. Wisconsin Gov.-elect David Crowley has already said he would sign a bill redrawing the state’s congressional map. Another possibility would seem to be Minnesota.

The GOP has far fewer apparent opportunities to draw more seats.

It could be dicey politically for Democrats to jump back into redrawing maps. But Republicans clearly started it and drew many more seats for themselves.

And if Democrats don’t take advantage of what opportunities they have, this whole exercise could still benefit the GOP — even though it clearly didn’t do Trump, the person who pushed it so hard in the first place, much good.

评论

发表回复

您的邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用 * 标注

湘ICP备2026001899号-2