2026年10月22日 美国东部时间早上6:00 / 福克斯新闻
密歇根州参议院候选人在11月3日大选前的第二场也是最后一场辩论中正面交锋
作者:利奥·布里塞尼奥
前联邦众议员迈克·罗杰斯与其民主党对手阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德周三晚间在第二次密歇根州参议院辩论中互相激烈抨击。
前联邦调查局特工、共和党籍联邦参议院候选人罗杰斯与埃尔赛义德就个人嘲讽、指控以及深刻分歧展开交锋,这些争议也成为美国最受期待的参议院选举之一的标志性事件。
以下是这场激烈对决中几个最值得关注的时刻。
共和党联邦参议院提名候选人迈克·罗杰斯在阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德赢得党内初选后,直接向密歇根州民主党人拉票。(莎拉·赖斯/盖蒂图片社;杰夫·科瓦斯基/法新社 via 盖蒂图片社)
埃尔赛义德指责罗杰斯支持特朗普对伊朗开战
作为罗杰斯与唐纳德·特朗普总统立场一致的证据,埃尔赛义德指责他支持对伊朗发动战争,埃尔赛义德本人将这场冲突描述为“漫无目的”。
“他处处都要发动战争,现在也不会从这场战争中收手。他支持这场战争,”埃尔赛义德说道。
“如果你不信我的话,我希望你留心观察。周日,唐纳德·特朗普将应迈克·罗杰斯之邀前来,提醒大家,唐纳德·特朗普实际上是通过迈克·罗杰斯参选的。他们在这场战争上完全站在同一阵线,而你们正在为此付出代价,”他补充道,这里指的是罗杰斯即将举行的一场竞选活动。
罗杰斯迅速反击,重申了两人第一场辩论中的一个时刻:埃尔赛义德拒绝回答以色列或伊朗对美国构成的威胁更大这一问题。
“我的对手甚至都不敢谴责伊斯兰革命卫队——伊朗的恐怖主义执行机构,还不认为伊朗比以色列更危险。这绝对是不可接受的,”罗杰斯说道。
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406549568112
罗杰斯重提穆斯林兄弟会指控引发爆炸性时刻
辩论期间,罗杰斯一度指责埃尔赛义德删除了有关削减警察经费的社交媒体内容——这一进步派立场在2020年乔治·弗洛伊德去世后在极左翼民主党人中流传开来。
“我跟你说,他确实呼吁过削减警察经费……[而且]他删除了所有相关内容。你为什么要这么做?你为什么要花那么多时间删除所有这些材料?X条视频、评论、播客。为什么?因为他当时对削减警察经费充满热情,”罗杰斯说道。
“事实上,他还曾请求埃及穆斯林兄弟会领导人穆尔西也在埃及削减警察经费,”罗杰斯补充道,这里指的是与该组织有关联的埃及前总统。
这番言论引发了埃尔赛义德的强烈反应,他在整个竞选过程中一直回避有关与穆斯林兄弟会存在关联的质疑。
“他一直在提这个关于与该组织有关联的问题,”埃尔赛义德说道。“这真的很掉价。”
尽管福克斯新闻数字频道并未发现埃尔赛义德与穆斯林兄弟会之间存在任何关联,但批评人士指出,埃尔赛义德与穆斯林学生协会(MSA)存在联系。该组织被列为穆斯林兄弟会成员穆罕默德·阿克拉姆撰写的北美战略备忘录的一部分。
据《大学修复》报道,2007年埃尔赛义德在密歇根大学读大四时,曾担任该校穆斯林学生协会分会的副主席。
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406536920112
罗杰斯抨击扩大政府承诺的隐性成本
整场辩论中,埃尔赛义德一再重申扩大医疗补助等政府项目的承诺,并提出“让你的钱包鼓起来”的举措,这一口号一直是他竞选活动的核心内容。
但罗杰斯无疑对这些承诺提出了质疑,辩称这些政策的代价将比这位民主党候选人所承认的要高得多。
“想想他刚才谈到的三件事。让你的钱包鼓起来。这是个很棒的口号,但背后毫无实质内容。事实上,当他那些与民主社会主义者立场一致的政策付诸实施时,到最后你能保住一条裤子就算不错了,”罗杰斯说道。
“全民医保。他不会告诉你你要缴纳多少税,而且你会失去私人医疗保险。这些都不是真正的解决方案。这些解决方案只会让你的生活更糟糕,还会剥夺你在医疗保健方面的选择权。”
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6401042129112
罗杰斯称埃尔赛义德在人工智能监管问题上“说漏了嘴”
当被问及人工智能监管问题时,阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德简要提到,他将支持“由民主任命的人员担任这些人工智能公司的董事会成员”,并称此举是为了应对他所说的对劳动力构成的生存威胁。
罗杰斯抓住这一点,指责埃尔赛义德公开表达了对私营企业实施公共管控的意愿。
“他说漏了嘴,”罗杰斯说道。
“他希望政府介入这些企业。这就是美国民主社会主义者(DSA)的做派。[他们]会插手你的企业和你的未来。所以你真的应该停下来想一想,你是否想要一个希望政府介入这些公司的人来掌权?”罗杰斯补充道。
值得注意的是,阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德并未正式获得美国民主社会主义者的背书,也未明确表示支持该组织的纲领。即便如此,他还是背书了多位获得该组织支持的候选人,并获得了他们的背书。其中,埃尔赛义德去年支持了自称社会主义者的纽约市长佐赫兰·曼达尼的竞选活动。
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406147186112
埃尔赛义德在关于第二修正案的快问快答环节陷入争议
辩论接近尾声时,民主党候选人埃尔赛义德指责罗杰斯拒绝就实施枪支购买普遍背景调查的问题给出肯定或否定的回答,罗杰斯随即予以反击。
“这得看情况。这得看情况,”罗杰斯说道。
“这不难啊。你看,就是这么不可靠,”埃尔赛义德打趣道。
罗杰斯反击称,埃尔赛义德在参选参议院之前的言论中曾呼吁废除第二修正案。
“你想要废除第二修正案。你为什么不谈谈这个?”
罗杰斯指的是2023年发布在YouTube上的一段视频,视频中埃尔赛义德将持枪权比作医疗权。
“如果我们修改宪法,修订这项修正案,不再保留持枪权,而是将其改为拥有医疗保健的权利,那会怎么样?”埃尔赛义德说道。
他为这项提议标榜利他主义,称这样能挽救更多生命,并反对个人拥有枪支,转而建议只有指定的社区团体如警察部队才能配备枪支。
该视频现已设为私密。
密歇根州民主党参议院候选人阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德在竞选期间一直否认自己想要削减警察经费,但在一段被挖出的视频中,他曾问道:“警察真的需要使用枪支吗?”(莎拉·赖斯/盖蒂图片社)
点击此处下载福克斯新闻应用程序
随着第二场辩论落下帷幕,埃尔赛义德和罗杰斯已经完成了预定的所有辩论,不太可能在大选前再次交锋。两人均已通过党内初选,获得了各自政党的提名,将在11月3日的密歇根州大选中正面交锋。
辩论结束后,密歇根州共和党主席吉姆·伦内斯塔德在给福克斯新闻数字频道的一份声明中表示:“迈克·罗杰斯再次证明了为什么他是密歇根人想要在美国参议院看到的务实、沉稳的人选。我们承受不起阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德的极左翼大政府政策,也不能冒险选举一个与哈森·皮克尔之流一同竞选,而且似乎为布卢姆菲尔德希尔斯针对儿童和犹太社区的可怕恐怖袭击辩护的人。”
利奥·布里塞尼奥是福克斯新闻数字频道国会团队的政治记者,此前曾在《世界杂志》担任记者。
El-Sayed, Rogers clash over Muslim Brotherhood, Trump and guns: 5 fiery debate moments
October 22, 2026 6:00am EDT / Fox News
The Michigan Senate candidates faced off in their second and final debate before the Nov 3 general election
By Leo Briceno
Former Rep. Mike Rogers and his Democratic opponent, Abdul El-Sayed, tore into each other at their second Michigan Senate debate Wednesday evening.
Rogers, a former FBI special agent and the Republican U.S. Senate candidate, clashed with El-Sayed over the personal barbs, accusations and fierce divides that have defined one of the countryâs most anticipated Senate elections.
Here are some of the most noteworthy moments from the fiery faceoff.
Republican Senate nominee Mike Rogers is making a direct pitch to Michigan Democrats following Abdul El-Sayedâs primary victory.(Sarah Rice/Getty Images; Jeff Kowalsky/AFP via Getty Images)
El-Sayed accuses Rogers of backing Trumpâs war with Iran
As evidence of Rogersâ alignment with President Donald Trump, El-Sayed accused him of backing the war in Iran, a conflict El-Sayed himself described as “aimless.”
“He’s got a war for everything, and he won’t back off the war now. He supports this war,” El-Sayed said.
“If you don’t believe me, I want you to pay attention. On Sunday, when Donald Trump comes here at the invitation of Mike Rogers to remind you that, in fact, Donald Trump is on the ballot through Mike Rogers. They are hip to hip on this war, and you are paying the cost,” he added, referring to one of Rogers’ upcoming campaign events.
Rogers quickly fired back, reiterating a moment from their first debate when El-Sayed refused to answer whether Israel or Iran posed a greater threat to the U.S.
“My opponent can’t even condemn the [Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps], which is the terrorist enforcement arm of Iran, and doesn’t believe Iran is any more dangerous than Israel. This is an absolute nonstarter,” Rogers said.
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406549568112
THE MEDICARE FOR ALL TRADE-OFFS SOCIALISTS AREN’T TALKING ABOUT, ACCORDING TO EXPERTS
Rogers sparks explosive moment with resurfaced Muslim Brotherhood accusations
At one point during the debate, Rogers accused El-Sayed of deleting social media content about defunding the police â a progressive stance that circulated among far-left Democrats in 2020 after the death of George Floyd.
“I will tell you this: he did call for defunding the police ⦠[and] he deleted all of this material. Why would you do that? Why would you go through and take all of that time to delete all of the material? X videos, comments, podcast. Why? Because he was passionate about defunding the police,” Rogers said.
“As a matter of fact, he asked the Muslim Brotherhood head, Morsi, in Egypt to defund the police there, too,” Rogers added, referring to the former Egyptian president associated with the group.
The last remark triggered a fierce reaction from El-Sayed, who has fended off questions about ties to the Muslim Brotherhood throughout his campaign.
“He keeps raising this question about this association with the organization,” El-Sayed said. “It’s really quite beneath you.”
Although Fox News Digital has not discovered any links between El-Sayed and the Muslim Brotherhood, critics have pointed to El-Sayed’s ties to the Muslim Students Association (MSA), a group listed as part of a strategy memorandum for North America written by one of the Muslim Brotherhoodâs members, Mohamed Akram.
El-Sayed served as the vice president of the MSA chapter at the University of Michigan during his time there as a senior in 2007, according to College Fix.
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406536920112
ABDUL EL-SAYED’S ALLEGED FAMILY TIES TO MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD SURFACE AFTER DENYING ANY LINK DURING NBC INTERVIEW
Rogers blasts hidden costs of expanding government promises
Throughout the night, El-Sayed doubled down on promises to expand government programs like Medicaid and measures to “put money in your pocket,” a refrain that has been a cornerstone of his campaign.
But Rogers made sure to cast doubt on those commitments, arguing that the policies would carry with them a heftier price tag than the Democratic nominee would acknowledge.
“So think of all of the three things he just talked about. Put money in your pockets. It’s a great slogan. There’s nothing behind it. Matter of fact, when his Democratic socialist-aligned policies are engaged, you’ll be lucky to have a d— pair of pants when you’re done,” Rogers said.
“Medicare for all. He doesn’t tell you how much taxes you have to get charged, and you lose your private health insurance. These aren’t real solutions. These are solutions that are going to make your life more miserable. And it’s going to take away your choices in healthcare.”
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6401042129112
Rogers claims El-Sayed said âquiet part out loudâ on AI regulation
When asked about AI regulation, Abdul El-Sayed briefly mentioned he would support having “democratically appointed folks on the board of these AI corporations,” citing what he described as an existential threat to the workforce.
Rogers seized on the moment, accusing El-Sayed of verbalizing a desire to exercise public control of private companies.
“He said the quiet part out loud,” Rogers said.
“He wants government to go into these businesses. That is the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). [They] come in for your business and your future. And so, you need to really stop for a minute and think about, do you want somebody who wants the government involved in these companies?” Rogers added.
Notably, Abdul El-Sayed has not officially received an endorsement from the DSA, nor has he affirmed the groupâs platform. Even so, he has endorsed and received endorsements from a number of candidates who have received the DSAâs backing. Among them, El-Sayed supported New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a self-proclaimed socialist, in his bid for office last year.
https://www.foxnews.com/video/6406147186112
ROGERS WARNS MICHIGAN VOTERS AGAINST EL-SAYEDâS âEXTREMEâ AGENDA AHEAD OF ELECTION
El-Sayed gets heat in rapid-fire round over Second Amendment
At the close of the debate, Rogers fired back at El-Sayed when the Democratic candidate needled him for refusing to answer yes or no to a question about implementing universal background checks for gun purchases.
“It all depends. It all depends,” Rogers said.
“Itâs not hard. Look at that. So dependable,” El-Sayed quipped.
Rogers fired back, noting that El-Sayed had once called for doing away with the Second Amendment in comments he had made before he launched his Senate bid.
“You want to ban the Second Amendment. Why donât you talk about that?”
Rogers was alluding to a video published on YouTube in 2023 in which El-Sayed had compared the right to bear arms to a right to healthcare.
“What if we tweaked the Constitution, amended the amendment, and instead of the right to bear arms, we change it to the right to have healthcare?” El-Sayed said.
Michigan Senate Democratic candidate Abdul El-Sayed has spent his campaign denying he wanted to defund the police, but in an unearthed clip he asked, “Do police really need to use guns?”(Sarah Rice/Getty Images)
He claimed altruism in the proposal, saying more people would live and arguing against individuals owning firearms, instead suggesting that only designated community-based groups like police forces should be issued firearms.
The video has since been made private.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
With their second debate now in the rearview mirror, El-Sayed and Rogers have closed out their scheduled debates and are unlikely to meet again until after the election. Having cleared their respective primaries and secured their parties’ nominations, the pair will face off in Michiganâs general election on Nov. 3.
After the debate, MIGOP Chairman Jim Runestad said in a statement to Fox News Digital: “Mike Rogers demonstrated yet again why he is the commonsense, steady hand Michiganders want to see in the U.S. Senate. We cannot afford Abdul El-Sayed’s far-left, big-government policies, and we cannot risk electing a person who campaigns with the likes of Hasan Piker and seemingly justified the horrific terrorist attack targeting children and the Jewish community in Bloomfield Hills.”
Leo Briceno is a politics reporter for the congressional team at Fox News Digital. He was previously a reporter with World Magazine.
发表回复