2026-10-21T21:21:00-0400 / 哥伦比亚广播公司新闻（CBS News）
撰稿
亚伦·纳瓦罗 数字记者
亚伦·纳瓦罗是哥伦比亚广播公司新闻的数字记者，曾报道2024年大选，还曾在2021和2022年选举周期担任哥伦比亚广播公司新闻政治部门的助理制片人。
查看完整简历
更新时间：2026年10月21日 / 美国东部时间晚上11:17 / 哥伦比亚广播公司新闻
在谷歌上添加哥伦比亚广播公司
共和党人迈克·罗杰斯与民主党人阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德于周三在密歇根州参议院竞争激烈的选战中，展开了第二场也是最后一场线下辩论。埃尔赛义德多次辩称，其对手在参议院中会成为特朗普总统的“提线木偶”，而罗杰斯则指责对手不可信任，并试图隐瞒其过往的极左翼立场。
这场势均力敌的选战是美国11月中期选举中最受关注的竞争之一，或将决定哪个政党能掌控参议院。民主党希望借助特朗普的不受欢迎程度，以及选民对通胀和伊朗战争的不满情绪赢得选举。共和党则试图利用埃尔赛义德等进步派与温和派民主党人在中东政策和“全民医保”议题上的分歧拉拢选民。
参议院候选人阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德（左）与迈克·罗杰斯于2026年10月21日在密歇根州绍斯菲尔德的WXYZ电视台辩论结束后握手。罗宾·巴克森- pooled / 盖蒂图片社
埃尔赛义德称罗杰斯的竞选纲领是“让美国再次伟大（MAGA）式的愿景”，并指出这位前国会议员“在特朗普所有最糟糕的政策上都与他完全站在一起，这些政策推高了油价，让民众买不起 groceries（食品杂货）”。这位曾担任卫生官员的民主党人还在回应攻击言论时邀请观众玩“MAGA宾果游戏”。
“他会向唐纳德·特朗普屈服，因为他就是这个人的提线木偶，”埃尔赛义德说道。
罗杰斯随即反驳称：“他想把这场辩论扯到唐纳德·特朗普身上。这个宾果游戏应该改成：‘他能在多少个回答里提到特朗普？’”
辩论结束后，当被记者问及是否计划出席周日特朗普在密歇根州的集会（这一议题正是埃尔赛义德提出的）时，罗杰斯表示他会参加，但还不清楚所有最终细节。
在辩论中，罗杰斯辩称埃尔赛义德从未坦诚对待自己的竞选纲领，指责对方“一贯欺骗”。
“想想看：如今有太多民主党人公开表示不会投票给阿卜杜勒·埃尔赛义德，因为他过于极端，”罗杰斯说道。他还声称自己“在犹太民主党选民中表现异常出色，这些人实际上感到恐惧”，暗指部分社区成员不愿支持经常批评以色列政府的埃尔赛义德。
本次辩论比本月初两人的首次对决要温和一些，首次辩论中几乎每个回答环节都充满了辱骂和打断。但本场辩论依然火药味十足。
其中一个最为激烈的时刻出现在罗杰斯试图将埃尔赛义德与穆斯林兄弟会联系起来，并暗示他与哈马斯等恐怖组织拥有相同支持者之时——埃尔赛义德此前已强烈否认了这些指控。
本月早些时候，多家媒体报道了埃尔赛义德同父异母妹妹的社交媒体帖子，内容称这位民主党候选人的母亲曾支持穆斯林兄弟会，该组织是在其祖国埃及成立的伊斯兰团体和政治运动。
埃尔赛义德否认与该组织有任何关联，并指出他年幼时父母就离婚了，并非由生母抚养长大。罗杰斯称埃尔赛义德试图将自己塑造成“受害者”。
“你可以嬉皮笑脸，说得冠冕堂皇，但我要告诉你，这对我们的国家安全是一种威胁，”罗杰斯说道。辩论结束后他告诉记者，他质疑埃尔赛义德如果当选是否能获得安全许可。
埃尔赛义德称这些指控“令人羞耻”。
“他不断提起这个与某个组织的关联，而我从未加入过该组织，就因为我那位在密苏里州当护士的母亲？”这位民主党人说道，“这毫无道理，实际上迈克，这真的太掉价了。”
埃尔赛义德就伊朗战争向罗杰斯施压，指出这场冲突是消费品价格高企的原因，并称这位共和党人是“凡事都主张开战”的鹰派人物。
“我们需要一项《战争权力决议》，而不是一位会与唐纳德·特朗普完全站在一起的参议员，这场战争从一开始就毫无意义，现在更是如此，”当被问及如何降低物价时，埃尔赛义德说道。
罗杰斯呼吁结束这场战争，但也在辩论舞台上表示，如果伊朗控制霍尔木兹海峡或研发核武器，油价可能会进一步上涨。
主持人向埃尔赛义德提问，是否认为伊朗对美国国家安全构成重大威胁。这是首次辩论中类似问题的变体，当时埃尔赛义德被问及伊朗和以色列哪个威胁更大，他称这是“荒谬的假设”。
埃尔赛义德周三表示，“毫无疑问，伊朗构成了威胁”，但他辩称，奥巴马时代限制伊朗核计划的协议“已经遏制了这一威胁”。特朗普在其第一任期内废除了该协议。
罗杰斯称伊朗“绝对”是威胁，并辩称埃尔赛义德此前关于伊朗的言论“如果你要派人……前往美国参议院，那绝对是行不通的”。
与此同时，罗杰斯就埃尔赛义德的一些进步政策观点向其施压，包括他对“全民医保”——一项单一支付者医疗保健计划——的支持。
“钱装进你口袋？等他的政策落地后，你能有一条像样的裤子穿就不错了，”罗杰斯说道，他辩称埃尔赛义德的政策将需要大幅加税。
埃尔赛义德回应称：“如今，把钱从你口袋里掏走的正是那些为他的竞选活动捐款的大公司。”辩论结束后，当被哥伦比亚广播公司新闻问及该计划的成本时，埃尔赛义德辩称，如果该计划得以实施，成本将低于当前的医疗开支，并表示该纲领得到了两党支持。
在关税问题上，埃尔赛义德批评特朗普的关税政策，但表示他对某些进口关税持开放态度。他说：“你不能一下子把所有化疗药物都用上，同一时间全部用上。”
罗杰斯称总统的关税政策是“好坏参半”，他质疑与加拿大的贸易战，但表示“制造业回流正在进行中”。
In final Michigan Senate debate, El-Sayed ties Rogers to Trump, while Rogers says El-Sayed is untrustworthy
2026-10-21T21:21:00-0400 / CBS News
By
Aaron Navarro Digital Reporter
Aaron Navarro is a CBS News digital reporter. He covered the 2024 elections and was previously an associate producer for the CBS News political unit in the 2021 and 2022 election cycles.
Read Full Bio
Updated on: October 21, 2026 / 11:17 PM EDT / CBS News
Add CBS News on Google
Republican Mike Rogers and Democrat Abdul El-Sayed clashed onstage Wednesday during the second, and final, debate in the increasingly bitter Michigan Senate race. El-Sayed repeatedly argued his opponent is and would be a “sock puppet” for President Trump in the Senate, while Rogers cast his opponent as untrustworthy and trying to run from past, further-left positions.
The neck-and-neck race is one of the nation’s most closely watched contests in the November midterms and could help determine which party wins control of the Senate. Democrats hope to take advantage of Mr. Trump’s unpopularity and voters’ frustration with inflation and the Iran War. Republicans have sought to capitalize on divisions between progressives like El-Sayed and more moderate Democrats on Middle East policy and Medicare for All.
Senate candidates Abdul El-Sayed, left, Mike Rogers shake hands after their debate on Oct. 21, 2026, at WXYZ-TV in Southfield, Michigan. Robin Buckson-Pool / Getty Images
El-Sayed called Rogers’ platform a “MAGA vision” and argued the former congressman “stand[s] hip-to-hip with Donald Trump on all of his worst policies, the policies that are raising the price of your gas, making it impossible to afford your groceries.” The Democratic former health official responded to attack lines by inviting the audience to play “MAGA bingo.”
“He’s going to bend to Donald Trump because he is a sock puppet for the man,” said El-Sayed.
Rogers pushed back at one point, saying: “He wants to make this about Donald Trump. The bingo game ought to be: ‘How many times can he put Trump in any answer?’”
Asked by reporters after the debate if he’s planning to attend Mr. Trump’s Michigan rally on Sunday, which El-Sayed brought up, Rogers said he’d go but didn’t know all the final details yet.
During the debate, Rogers argued El-Sayed has not been honest about his platform, accusing him of engaging in a “pattern of deception.”
“Think about this: there are so many Democrats who are coming out today and saying they can’t vote for Abdul El-Sayed because he’s too extreme,” Rogers said. He also claimed he’s “doing exceptionally well with Jewish Democrats who are literally afraid,” alluding to some community members’ reluctance to support El-Sayed, a frequent critic of the Israeli government.
The debate was somewhat tamer than the two candidates’ first faceoff earlier this month, which featured insults and interruptions in virtually every answer. But it was still testy.
One of the more contentious moments came after Rogers tried to link El-Sayed to the Muslim Brotherhood and suggested he had the same supporters as terror groups like Hamas — allegations El-Sayed has vehemently pushed back against.
Earlier this month, several news outlets reported on social media posts by El-Sayed’s half sister suggesting the Democratic candidate’s mother had supported the Muslim Brotherhood, an Islamist group and political movement founded in her home country of Egypt.
El-Sayed has disavowed any connection to the organization, and has noted that he wasn’t raised by his birthmother since his parents divorced when he was young. Rogers said El-Sayed was trying to make himself look like “a victim.”
“You can grin and you can smile and you can talk real pretty, but I’m going to tell you what, that is a risk to our national security,” Rogers said. He told reporters after the debate that he questions whether El-Sayed can get a security clearance if elected.
El-Sayed called the allegations “shameful.”
“He keeps raising this question about this association with an organization I’ve never been a part of, because [of] my mom, who’s a nurse in Missouri?” the Democrat said. “It doesn’t make any sense, and it’s actually really quite beneath you, Mike.”
El-Sayed pressed Rogers on the Iran war, pointing to the conflict as the cause of high consumer prices and casting the Republican as a hawk who has “a war for everything.”
“We need a War Powers Resolution, rather than a senator who is going to stand hip-to-hip with Donald Trump on this war that made no sense when it started and certainly makes no sense now,” El-Sayed said when asked how he would bring costs down.
Rogers has called on the war to end, but also said on the debate stage that if Iran is allowed to control the Strait of Hormuz or build a nuclear weapon that gas could rise even higher.
The moderators asked El-Sayed whether he views Iran as a significant threat to U.S. national security. It was a variation on a question during the first debate, when El-Sayed was asked whether Iran or Israel is a bigger threat, which he called a “ridiculous hypothetical.”
El-Sayed said Wednesday that “there’s no doubt that Iran has posed a threat,” but he argued “that threat had been contained” by the Obama-era deal that limited Iran’s nuclear program. Mr. Trump ended that deal during his first term in office.
Rogers said Iran is “absolutely” a threat and argued El-Sayed’s previous answers on Iran were “an absolute nonstarter if you’re going to send somebody … to the United States Senate.”
Meanwhile, Rogers pushed El-Sayed on some of his progressive policy views, including his support for Medicare for All, a single-payer healthcare plan.
“Money in your pocket? You’ll be lucky to have a damn pair of pants when you’re done,” said Rogers, arguing El-Sayed’s policies would require significant tax hikes.
El-Sayed responded by saying: “Right now, the folks pulling the money out of your pocket are the big corporations who are buying his campaign.” Asked by CBS News after the debate about how much the plan would cost, El-Sayed argued if implemented it’d be less expensive than the costs of healthcare currently, and said the platform has bipartisan support.
On tariffs, El-Sayed criticized Mr. Trump’s tariffs but said he is open to some import duties. He said, “You don’t give all the chemo all at once, all at the same time.”
Rogers called the president’s tariffs a “mixed bag,” questioning the trade war with Canada but saying the “reshoring of manufacturing is underway.”
发表回复